The ICRS 2020 scientific session program is divided into 15 overarching themes. Each of the themes listed below includes a series of specialised sessions as well as an open session.
Open sessions cover all aspects of a particular theme that are not addressed by its specialised sessions. Theme 14 is an exception, which only includes an open session and no specialised sessions.
Coral reef environments have experienced a variety of climate boundary conditions during the recent and the geological past. The varying climatic conditions were accompanied by transient, oscillatory and abrupt changes in environmental parameters and sea level affecting reef ecosystem and population dynamics. Studying reefs of the past enables us to place observed changes in modern reefs into a long-term context. Coral reefs serve as archives of their own past. Studying the environmental and climatic forcing experienced during their lifetime can substantially expand our knowledge of reef ecosystem dynamics under varying climatic and environmental conditions, which is otherwise based mainly on direct observations for the last few decades. Combining observational reef monitoring with environmental information from the past might improve future projections and guide management strategies for modern reef ecosystems.
Kristine DeLong 1, Diane Thompson2, Thomas Felis3, Hali Kilbourne4
1 Louisiana State University (Baton Rouge, LA, USA)
2 University of Arizona (Tucson, AZ, USA)
3 MARUM, University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
4 University of Maryland (College Park, MD, USA)
The tropical oceans are uniquely positioned to serve as the pulse of climate change and climate variability since they contain warm pools that feed vast amounts of evaporation to the atmosphere driving the climate system. The lack of instrumental observations in the tropical oceans, both spatially and temporally, is a major hindrance to understanding climate variability and resolving climate model biases in the tropics. Long-lived massive corals contain records of past ocean conditions in their skeletons that can be used to understand climate variability in the recent past and in other warm periods, such as the Last Interglacial (125 ka) and Mid-Holocene (5-6 ka). One of the largest sources of climate variability is El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) that occurs in the Tropical Pacific Ocean and impacts far flung regions. El Niño events during past 30 years have also driven higher reef temperatures leading to coral bleaching for large number of coral reefs. The Inter-American Seas (Gulf of Mexico and Caribbean Sea) is another prominent HotSpot for future climate change impacts including more intense tropical cyclones and droughts. Therefore, it is of foremost importance to expand our observational record, using corals as climate archives, to understand climate variability and extreme events so we can better predict future impacts of climate extremes on coral reefs. There is a strong need for a more comprehensive, end-to-end approach for climate assessments at a basin scale including better integration of paleoclimatic evidence, atmospheric and oceanic observations, physical understanding, model evaluation, and future projections. This session seeks contributions to increase our understanding of tropical climate variability in the past, present, and future using observations, coral and other marine paleoclimate proxies, and model simulations.
Aaron O'Dea 1, Erin Dillon2, Loren McClenachan3, John Pandolfi 4
1 Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute (Bocas del Toro, Panama)
2 University of California Santa Barbara (Santa Barbara, CA, USA)
3 Colby College (Waterville, ME, USA)
4 University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
To tackle the future of coral reefs it is essential to understand their ecological and environmental histories. Consequently, the use of historical data in coral reef ecology is expanding. Analytical approaches are maturing, compelling sources of data are being uncovered, and historians, paleontologists and archeologists are collaborating more fluidly with marine biologists and conservationists. This multidisciplinary session will explore how paleoecological, historical, and archeological data can reveal mechanisms of natural and human-driven change in coral reef communities to better understand how they function, both today and in the future. Submissions are welcomed on, but not limited to: incorporating spatial and temporal variation into baselines; resolving drivers of change in ecological structure; identifying legacy effects, non-analogue communities and refugia; developing emerging methods (e.g ancient DNA); and improving dialogue with reef managers, conservationists, and policymakers.
Henry C. Wu1, Delphine Dissard2, Jens Zinke3, Nathalie F. Goodkin4,5
1 Leibniz Centre for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 IRD-Sorbonne Universités (Paris, France)
3 University of Leicester (Leicester, United Kingdom)
4 Nanyang Technological University (Singapore)
5 American Museum of Natural History (New York, NY, USA)
Our understanding of current and future anthropogenic impacts (e.g. thermal stress and ocean acidification) on corals and coral reef ecosystems is severely limited due to the lack of reliable long-term monitoring and limited geographical coverage. Skeletal records from living and fossil, and tropical or subtropical biogenic carbonates such as surface and deep-sea corals, sclerosponges, bivalves, and foraminifera are key archives of environmental variability over historical time-scales. These records not only extend short instrumental records that started during the industrial era, but also allow for environmental reconstructions at unconstrained locations. Stable isotopes (e.g. δ11B, δ13C, δ15N) and trace elements (e.g. B/Ca, Sr/Ca, Li/Mg, etc.) incorporated into skeletons of calcifying organisms provide an indirect tool to reconstruct variations in seawater and calcification pH, 13C Suess Effect, DIC and carbonate chemistry, thermal stress, sediment and riverine discharge or nutrient loading, light intensity, water mass dynamics, and coral performance in extreme environments. This session aims to present reconstructions that identify the most prevalent stressors on corals and coral reef ecosystems and assess the interaction of multiple stressors on their resilience through time. In particular, we welcome regional to global scale contributions that characterize and precisely quantify recent or historical trends of OA, coral responses to past bleaching events, biologically mediated calcification mechanisms and/or "vital effects", and their sensitivities to environmental changes. Contributors may include coral biologists and physiologists who have concerns about the fidelity and limits of proxies (e.g. calibration, analytical issues, application) or analyzing past bleaching or stress events using geochemical techniques. Ecological modelers working to increase our understanding of the impacts of OA on the calcification of corals and reef community are also encouraged.
Daniel Harris1, Jody Webster2, Stephanie Duce3, Ana Vila-Concejo2
1 The University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
2 The University of Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
3 James Cook University (Townsville, Australia)
In recent decades the decline in coral cover, recurrent global mass bleaching events and observations of sea level rise suggest that substantial long-term change in coral reef and coastal systems is already occurring. Predictions suggest that changes in climate and oceanographic conditions over the next 100 years will exceed the range observed during the last ≈80 years of scientific coral reef observations. This presents a substantial problem in both predicting and managing the future states of coral reef systems in a warmer world. Periods in the past may offer insights into the future trajectory of coral reef systems as they navigate a world of warming temperatures, rising sea levels, and changes in oceanographic conditions and water quality. Developing our understanding of geological reef development and the physical and environmental processes that have governed this development will provide crucial information regarding reef change over many spatio-temporal scales, from yearly to millennial, and from individual reefs to entire oceans. We seek submissions focused on understanding the environmental and physical processes that govern coral reef development, over multiple spatial and temporal scales, in order to provide some insights into the future of reef systems. Relevant fields of research include, coral reef geology and geomorphology, sea level research, climate change, tropical coastal processes and water quality, coral reef physical processes and numerical modelling.
Amanda Godbold 1, Anna Weiss2, David Bottjer1
1 University of Southern California (Los Angeles, LA, USA)
2 University of Texas at Austin (Austin, TX, USA)
Corals have been around for millions of years and have survived some of the deadliest events in Earth's history, including the "Big Five" mass extinctions. Their resiliency begs the question, how do these seemingly delicate organisms persist? This session aims to unite paleoecology and modern ecology for the purpose of understanding the extinction, survival, and recovery of corals throughout time. Each discipline offers unique insight into these important topics. The geologic record offers an abundance of time allowing natural experiments in climate and environmental change to be viewed in their entirety. Fossil reefs allow us to explore the evolutionary history of reefs in response to environmental changes as well as extinction selectivity of coral species. The modern has exceptional resolution allowing for detailed analyses. Modern reefs enhance our understanding of ecological phase shifts and the importance of connectivity in the survival of these ecosystems. Combining insights from the past with modern observations provides a powerful perspective that can be used to tackle complex concepts such as the range shifts of corals due to climate change and the development of refugia.
Andrea Dutton1, Alessio Rovere 2
1 University of Florida (Gainsville, Fl, USA)
2 MARUM, University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
Fossil coral reefs are used by geoscientists to gather information on past sea level changes at many different time scales, from few hundred to several thousand years ago. Interdisciplinary collaborations between geoscientists and reef ecologists help to elucidate the paleo environments and the paleo water depths associated with fossil reef systems. This information is then coupled with radiometric dating of corals and geophysical models to understand the history of past sea level, land-based ice volume, and reef response. In this session, we welcome abstracts focusing on the different aspects related to the use of reefs as paleo sea level recorders, including dating and field techniques, particularly relevant sites, models of vertical land movements associated with reefs, rapid sea level changes recorded by reef environments, and reef response to past changes in sea level.
Thomas Felis1, Georg Heiss2, Kristine DeLong3
1 MARUM, University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
2 Freie Universität Berlin (Berlin, Germany)
3 Louisiana State University (Baton Rouge, LA, USA)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 1 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Reefs are the most biodiverse marine ecosystems. Their diverse populations of animals, microbes, plants, and algae evolve as interacting networks in space and time and understanding the underlying patterns and processes that shape their diversity at different spatial and temporal scales is the necessary knowledge for future management and conservation of reef habitats. This theme covers contributions concerned with taxonomy, systematics, phylogeography, and population genetics of all organisms. It also addresses topics such as niche definition, reproductive traits, developmental mechanisms and constraints, dispersal and distribution, competitivity and adaptive potential. Contributions in this theme will aid to evaluate organismic and evolutionary responses to changing environments.
Jacqueline Padilla-Gamino 1, Yossi Loya2, Saki Harii3, Elizabeth Lenz4, Tom Shlesinger 2
1 University of Washington (Seattle, USA)
2 Tel Aviv University (Tel Aviv, Israel)
3 Sesoko Station (Okinawa, Japan)
4 Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology (Kaneohe, HI, USA)
Reproduction represents the culmination of several physiological events within an individual's life, and is the first step in producing new recruits to marine ecosystems. With the aim of better understanding the factors that control the spawning synchrony and reproductive output of reef organisms, this session will bring together experts in different fields in order to share their findings on how environmental factors, and changes in the environment, can affect reproduction at the individual, population, and molecular levels. The session will highlight multidisciplinary research, including but not limited to the following topics: natural variability in reproductive cycles, parental effects, spawning synchronicity, chronobiology, phenology, gamete quality, fertilization success, larval dispersal, reproductive phenotypic plasticity, and the effects of environmental factors (light, ocean acidification, temperature, nutrients, pollutants, sedimentation) on the reproduction, settlement, and growth of new recruits. The session seeks to bring together scientists working in different coral ecosystems and from different regions of the world, to share novel insights and establish collaborations leading to an international coral-reef reproduction network that will integrate reproduction data from coral-reef organisms in different parts of the world. This will provide an immensely useful tool for the scientific community and coral-reef managers to track spawning events, generate long-term spawning time-series, and identify reproductive patterns over larger spatial and temporal scales. In turn, it will help us to better predict the effects of climate change on the reproductive success of corals, which is essential for the resilience and persistence of coral reefs and for the survival of many species in the tropical seas.
Malin Pinsky 1, Peter Buston2, Michael Berumen3, John Majoris3, Laura Gajdzik3
1 Rutgers State University (New Brunswick, NJ, USA)
2 Boston University (Boston, MA, USA)
3 KAUST (Thuwal, Saudi Arabia)
The dispersal of individuals among patchily distributed habitats connects marine populations across space, allowing recovery from disturbance, resilience in the face of chronic stressors, and even driving adaptive evolution in response to a changing environment. For this reason, understanding the causes and consequences of larval dispersal is a major goal of 21st century marine ecology, mainly in an effort to describe the probability of larval exchange, or connectivity, among populations. Despite advances in our understanding of why dispersal varies among species, we still know stunningly little about the causes of variation in dispersal among individuals within species. Intraspecific variation sets the stage for evolution and has important consequences for population dynamics, species interactions, and conservation efforts. Understanding intraspecific variation will require a much stronger integration of oceanography, behavior, genetics, physiology, and ecology and evolution. To coordinate current research efforts and determine the state of the field, we invite submissions from scientists conducting research on larval behavior, the genetic basis for larval dispersal traits, the physiology of dispersal, biophysical simulations of larval dispersal, the ecological consequences of dispersal kernels, the evolution of dispersal kernels, or other relevant topics. Experiments, observations, theory, simulations, field and lab studies are all welcome.
James Reimer 1, Danwei Huang2, Francesca Benzoni3
1 University of the Ryukyus (Nishihara, Japan)
2 National University of Singapore (Singapore)
3 University of Milano-Bicocca (Milan, Italy)
The myriad of life forms on the coral reef have traditionally been studied based on gross morphology, yet a wide variety of data ranging from small-scale morphology to DNA barcodes and genomic sequences have challenged the assumed order of many important reef groups. The sheer volume of data produced by these new approaches has enabled necessary revisionary work that is already impacting estimates of biodiversity at various spatial and temporal scales. In particular, geographic patterns are being updated, and extinct organisms can be studied alongside living ones, drawing a more accurate and holistic picture of coral reef biodiversity in an evolutionary perspective. This session focuses on findings from the integration of novel morphological, barcoding, genomic and transcriptomic techniques, as well as standardised sampling tools such as the Autonomous Reef Monitoring Structures, to uncover biodiversity, biogeographic and evolutionary patterns of coral reef organisms. The session will offer valuable perspectives on how modern taxonomy and evolutionary studies can contribute to the conservation of coral reefs.
Christopher Cornwall 1, Steeve Comeau2, Guillermo Diaz-Pulido3, Maggy Nugues4
1 Victoria University of Wellington (Wellington, New Zealand)
2 Sorbonne Université (Villefranche-sur-mer, France)
3 Griffith University (Brisbane, Australia)
4 PSL Research University (Perpignan, France)
Coralline algae are important species on coral reefs that act as a settlement substrate, cement together and create reefs. Despite their ecological importance, we still have limited information on their ecological role, physiology, calcification and taxonomy/systematics. Additionally, understanding causes of the variability in their responses to global and local environmental changes in lacking. This session aims to bring together researchers that are working on coralline algae with a particular focus on the effects of environmental change, taxonomy, systematics and evolution, physiology and calcification, ecology, and contribution to reef accretion for these key taxa. With respects to environmental change, we welcome research that varies across scales, from mechanistic physiological and molecular effects through to larger-scale studies estimating the contribution of coralline algae to the accretion and functioning of future coral reefs. We are particularly interested in studies that go beyond the effects of a single stressor, that investigate the potential for coralline algae to acclimate and/or adapt to environmental changes, assessments of the role of phylogeny, or those that assess changes in their ecological role or function and the implications for coral reef ecology.
Kelly E. Speare 1, Aaron C. Hartmann2, Kristen L. Marhaver3
1 University of California, Santa Barbara (Santa Barbara, CA, USA)
2 Harvard University (Cambridge, MA, USA)
3 CARMABI Research Station (Curacao)
Anthropocene coral reefs have undergone massive changes in coral abundance and community composition, motivating ecologists to predict potential trajectories for recovery and factors that could thwart recovery. A growing body of work has identified important pathways by which corals, and the conditions they experience, influence future generations of corals and the assembly of ecosystems around them. For example, corals in denser populations produce disproportionally more larvae than corals in diffuse populations, and environmental conditions can influence the quantity and quality of coral offspring via maternal effects. Transgenerational effects can further influence coral offspring through adaptation (genetic) or acclimatization (epigenetic, microbial, or viral) to environmental change. In degraded systems, relatively weedy coral species are necessary to facilitate natural recruitment and outplant survival of more fragile species. While reefs were once thought to undergo a small number of predictable phase shifts, new datasets reveal complex path dependencies that affect community assemblage on a site-by-site basis. Finally, the re-establishment of coral populations in heavily degraded sites has produced so-called "novel ecosystems" made up of non-traditional, yet ecologically functional, species assemblages. What will coral reefs look like in the next 100 years? How will today's remnant, resilient, and recovering reefs influence these trajectories? This session will bring together ideas from across disciplines to ask the broad question: How are the corals of today influencing the coral reefs of the future? We invite contributions that address this question at all levels, from individual corals, to populations, communities, and ecosystems. This session aims to be highly interdisciplinary, bringing together work from empirical, theoretical, and applied approaches from any reef system.
Götz B. Reinicke1, Willem Renema 2, Gert Wörheide3
1 German Oceanographic Museum (Stralsund, Germany)
2 Naturalis Biodiversity Center (Leiden, The Netherlands)
3 LMU München (München, Germany)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 2 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Coral reef systems depend on complex biological, geochemical and physical processes to maintain their immense biomass and -diversity. These intricate ecosystem functions are the basis for the many services provided to other organisms (including humans) or systems such as coastal protection, nutrient recycling and provision, or creation of habitats. As reef ecosystems shift to different states under the ever-increasing anthropogenic impact, these functions, and to that effect the services they provide, are also changing. This theme brings together different lines of research that investigate overarching or yet undescribed functions carried out by single organisms, holobionts, communities, or collectively by the entire reef ecosystem. Further, this theme encourages stimulating exchange across scientists from different disciplines, stakeholders, managers, and policy makers to identify functional changes in coral reefs and their impact on (desirable) services provided by the ecosystem.
David Bellwood 1, Peter Cowman2, Sterling Tebbett1, Michael McWilliam2
1 James Cook University (Townsville, Australia)
2 ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies (Townsville, Australia)
In a world that is changing fast, it is now widely recognized that one of the primary challenges is to protect the functions that sustain coral reefs. But what are these 'functions', and how do we begin to protect functions on coral reefs? This mini-symposium is designed to bring together all of the complex facets of research that fall under the banner of 'function' on coral reefs. Functions offer a language that transcends time and space: we can compare functional attributes over evolutionary timescales, across biogeographic realms, and among taxonomic groups. Functions demonstrably matter - the question is how do we identify the functions performed on coral reefs by different organisms, their evolutionary origins and their ecological relevance? This symposium aims to showcase the benefits of functional studies and highlight their potential benefits for the future of coral reefs, incorporating everything from the evolution of reef systems, through functional morphology, functional traits, functional biogeography and, finally, to ecosystem function. Incorporating evolutionary, ecological and management components, we will consider the history, use and application of functional approaches. There is merely one unifying theme - the value and vision of functional approaches for coral reef ecology.
Jennifer Matthews 1, Maggie Sogin2, Adrian Lutz 3
1 University of Technology Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
2 Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology (Bremen, Germany)
3 The University of Melbourne (Melbourne, Australia)
Molecular tools are well established to describe reef taxonomic diversity, but function is often largely inferred. Metabolic processes influence organism functions at the cellular, individual and ecosystem scale, and can be measured using cutting edge metabolomic and proteomic tools. This session will provide a stage for the presentation and discussion of current research of functional metabolic processes on coral reefs. An organisms' metabolic status determines its ability to grow, reproduce and withstand biotic/abiotic stressors. Furthermore, the exchange of small molecules between individuals, species and Kingdoms supports complex ecosystems which together serve as functional units of selection. While these are some of the more challenging processes to define in reef systems, research over the last decade has demonstrated the potential for functional analysis of metabolic processes and interactions to describe cellular function and to provide an important diagnostic tool for reef health. Metabolomics and proteomics are emerging disciplines in marine science that are well equipped to examine functional metabolic processes and chemical dialogues. Analyses can be conducted at the individual metabolite, pathway and organism levels, and are used to elucidate system-wide metabolic responses. The value of these research fields is reflected in the rapid growth in publications and research groups and increasing availability of open source tools/databases underpinning the utility of these -omics tools. Studies using these emerging technologies are already revealing key interactions and mechanisms regulating reef health and contributed crucial knowledge to research on coral bleaching, ocean acidification, symbiotic interactions, diseases, fish cytotoxins and nutrition across life stages. This session will introduce current approaches and showcase new techniques that will improve modelling efforts and inform conservation strategies to safeguard future reef health.
Michael Fox 1, Kristen Davis2, Jörg Wiedenmann3, Gareth Williams4
1 Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (Woods Hole, MA, USA)
2 University of California (Irvine, CA, USA)
3 University of Southampton (Southampton, UK)
4 Bangor University (Bangor, UK)
Shallow water coral reefs are traditionally considered nutritionally self-sustaining systems, capable of thriving in oligotrophic waters. But coral reefs exist across a wide range of oceanic nutrient concentrations, primary production, and anthropogenic impacts. Emerging evidence reveals that many reefs receive substantial inputs of exogenous nutrients from natural processes such as upwelling, internal waves, or lagoon flushing. These inputs can significantly increase background nutrient concentrations and enhance nearshore phytoplankton biomass. Under such conditions, many reefs exhibit higher coral cover, fish biomass, and overall ecosystem productivity. In contrast, nutrients associated with anthropogenic activities enter reef systems through agricultural runoff, sewage, or groundwater discharge where they often compromise ecosystem functioning. To date, much of the focus has been on the negative effects of nutrients on reef communities, while the synergistic roles of natural nutrient enrichment have received less attention. Resolving why nutrients can have contrasting impacts on different organisms and reef systems is an important next step in predicting the fate of coral reefs under future changes in coastal eutrophication and primary production. Recent advances in analytical techniques (e.g., compound-specific stable isotope analysis), high-resolution climate and biogeochemical modeling, and observational technologies (e.g., in situ and remote sensing) are creating opportunities to address the critical gaps in knowledge needed to develop innovative management strategies and refine predictions of coral reef trajectories. This session invites contributions from experimental, observational, and modeling studies that seek to quantify and understand the connections between nutrient supply, primary production, coral reef community structure and function, energy flow, and ecosystem resilience.
Ines D. Lange1, Tyler Cyronak2, Lauren T. Toth3, Coulson Lantz4
1 University of Exeter (Exeter, UK)
2 Nova Southeastern University (Dania Beach, FL, USA)
3 U.S. Geological Survey (St. Petersburg, FL, USA)
4 Southern Cross University (Lismore, Australia)
The production and maintenance of complex calcium carbonate structure is perhaps the most critical function of a healthy coral reef ecosystem, providing habitat for numerous marine species and acting as a breakwater that dissipates wave energy and protects shorelines. The build-up of reef framework is driven by counteracting rates of calcium carbonate production (i.e., calcification) and calcium carbonate breakdown and loss (i.e., dissolution, bioerosion, off-reef transport). Recent work has shown that the accelerating pace of global anthropogenic change, including increases in seawater temperature, ocean acidification, and sea level rise will significantly impact the capacity of reefs to sustain positive calcium carbonate budgets and associated ecosystem services. Although the footprint of anthropogenic disturbance will be different across marine regions and habitats, the repercussions for many reef ecosystems may be broadly similar: i) progressively shifting towards net negative calcium carbonate budget states; ii) becoming structurally flatter; and iii) having lower vertical growth rates. To understand how this progression will impact reef geo-ecological functions it is critical to understand both impacts on the biological processes that drive carbonate production on the reef surface and the breakdown processes that affect the accumulation of the underlying reef structure. For this session we invite contributions that explore calcium carbonate budgets and coral reef geo-ecological functions in the Anthropocene and address questions pertaining to: i) how changes in the abundance of key calcifying groups impact habitat complexity and reef budgets, ii) how the changing intensity of destructive processes impact reef budgets, iii) how rates of net reef accretion are changing now and predictions for the future, and iv) the implications of these changes for the maintenance of geo-ecological ecosystem services provided by coral reefs. We also welcome contributions that discuss novel approaches to quantifying calcium carbonate budgets, reef accretion, carbonate break-down and reef geo-ecological functions.
Anna Woodhead 1, Ruth Thurstan2, Tomas Chaigneau2, Susan Yee3
1 Lancaster University (Lancaster, UK)
2 University of Exeter (Exeter, UK)
3 U.S. Environment Protection Agency (Gulf Breeze, FL, USA)
Coral reef ecosystems underpin important benefits to people, known as ecosystem services. These contribute to human wellbeing but with current and future changes to reef social-ecological systems, how have and how will ecosystem services on coral reefs change? Ecosystem services occur via interactions between social and ecological systems, hence changes in ecosystem services could arise from ecological change, social change or multiple combinations therein. These might lead to emerging services, for instance the tropicalisation of temperate areas could underpin new fisheries. Changes in the use and importance of services could also occur. For example, changes in the socio-economic circumstances of individuals can modify the processes and motivations behind service use. Biophysical, social, economic and cultural changes all affect past and future coral reef ecosystem services, thus accurately capturing and predicting these interactions will require a broad disciplinary approach. We invite abstracts from different disciplines, looking at different ecosystem service types that address one or more of the following: -Evidence of changes in coral reef ecosystem services following social and/or ecological change in tropical coastal areas. -Novel approaches to capturing ecosystem service change. This could include looking to the future (e.g. scenarios) or to the past (e.g. syntheses of historical data). -Conceptual development and future directions. This could consider the types of evidence, knowledge and values that will be needed, as well as governance and management structures of coral reef social-ecological systems. Submissions should make explicit the approach they are taking towards capturing ecosystem services (e.g. historical ecology, ecological economics, contributions to wellbeing etc.). The session discussion will summarise how each talk addressed change in coral reef social-ecological systems with view to synthesising this work in an opinion piece.
Yvonne Sawall 1, Chiara Pisapia2, Andreas Andersson3
1 BIOS Bermuda Institute of Ocean Sciences (St. George's, Bermuda)
2 California State University, Northridge (Northridge, CA, USA)
3 Scripps Institution of Oceanography (La Jolla, CA, USA)
As a result of global climate change and local anthropogenic disturbances, coral reef ecosystem functions such as net organic carbon production and net calcification are likely to change during the twenty-first century. However, to advance our understanding of the potential responses of coral reefs to environmental change, we first need to understand the natural dynamics of reef metabolism and related biogeochemical processes. While we have learned extensively about organism responses to a range of environmental parameters in lab-based experiments, we have limited understanding about organism responses in-situ where multiple environmental factors act simultaneously and on different temporal and spatial scales. Furthermore, our current understanding is even more limited in terms of how organism performance scale to community and ecosystem scales, including how species interactions and ecological feedbacks affect the net metabolism. This is important to consider because the net metabolism alters seawater chemistry, which, in turn, may affect the performance of neighboring or downstream habitats and communities. In this session, we are particularly interested in contributions that assess the dynamics of organism, community and/or ecosystem metabolism and biogeochemical processes considering (i) multiple environmental factors, (ii) species interactions, (iii) lab-based versus in-situ approaches, (iv) different spatial and temporal scales (e.g., using up-scaling approaches) and/or (v) predictive models of reef metabolic function. We also welcome introductions of new methodologies advancing our understanding on reef metabolism dynamics at present and in a future warmer and more acidic ocean.
Benjamin Mueller1, Marta Ribes2, Cynthia Silveira3, Jasper de Goeij1
1 University of Amsterdam (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
2 Institut de Ciències del Mar (Barcelona, Spain)
3 San Diego State University (San Diego, CA, USA)
Since the first description of coral reefs it remains an enigma how such diverse and productive ecosystems can flourish in nutrient-poor waters, the equivalent to a marine dessert. It is becoming increasingly evident that certain element recycling pathways mediated by benthic holobionts (host plus associated microbiota) and free-living microbes play key roles in ecosystem functioning. For example, the transformation of dissolved organic matter (DOM; the largest, yet largely unavailable food source) to particles via the respective microbial and sponge loop reduce the loss of elements stored in this DOM to the open ocean and is considered pivotal to sustain reefs under oligotrophic conditions. However, global and local stressors cause shifts in benthic communities and affect levels and composition of organic and inorganic nutrients, as well as the stoichiometry of elements in reef waters. Efficient element recycling pathways that initially allowed reefs to evolve under nutrient-poor conditions, are now hypothesized to reinforce ongoing benthic shifts and the deterioration of these systems. Recent examples are the accumulation of microbial biomass at the expense of element transfer to higher trophic levels ("microbialization") and the release of organic and inorganic nutrients by sponges ("vicious circle"). Both theories suggest to stimulate an increase in opportunistic microbes causing low oxygen levels and detrimental effects on coral health, and to further fuel algal growth. This session invites abstracts on the latest findings on organic and inorganic element cycling by benthic holobionts and free-living microbes and their role in ecosystem function. The aim is to bring together studies from organism to ecosystem levels assessing the current status, making future projections, and discussing possible management interventions. Contributions from mangrove, seagrass, and deep-sea environments are encouraged to foster a broad interdisciplinary exchange.
Andreas Haas1, Christian Wild2
1 NIOZ and Utrecht University (Texel, The Netherlands)
2 University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 3 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Recent years have brought a changing imperative in life sciences sparked by the revolution of genomic tools to study the molecular composition and functional organization of organisms. The development of next-generation sequencing changed our understanding of microbial diversity associated with organisms and environments. There are now a multitude of studies that support the notion that 1) microbes are everywhere, 2) they appear orders of magnitude more diverse than anticipated, and 3) they associate with all organisms - plants, animals, fungi, and protists alike – to provide functions related to the biology of their respective host.
Consequently, interactions and communication mechanisms of members in these so-called holobionts presumably play a major role in maintaining host health, organismal homeostasis, and resilience to environmental disturbance. In this session, we invite presentations that report on studies related to microbial ecology of coral reef ecosystems, including the role of microbes in the structure and function of reef holobionts, effects of natural and anthropogenic disturbances on microbiomes of reef holobionts, recent efforts to identify new model systems, and the use of current model systems (e.g. Aiptasia) as a means to develop tools to study microbial function and manipulate microbiomes to improve resilience of coral reef-associated organisms.
Linda Wegley Kelly 1, Amy Apprill2, Craig Nelson3, Andreas Haas4
1 San Diego State University (San Diego, CA, USA)
2 Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (Woods Hole, MA, USA)
3 University of Hawaii at Manoa (Honolulu, HI, USA)
4 NIOZ and Utrecht University (Texel, The Netherlands)
This session welcomes work across scales and approaches that seeks to understand how microorganisms interact with coral reef biogeochemistry. Processes such as primary production, calcification, respiration, dissolution, nutrient remineralization and organic matter recycling all have well-established links to to reef microbes; however advances in technology offer new ways to investigate the linkages between specific microbial populations and their surrounding environment. The complexity of microbial communities in reefs, including planktonic, benthic and host associated habitats, demands deeper exploration of the interplay between microbes and biogeochemical fluxes which underpins coral reef biology. Microbes are also intimately involved in worldwide changes on coral reefs, including bleaching, diseases and phase shifts of dominant benthic macro-organisms. Furthermore, effective coral reef management in the face of local and climatic stressors requires a clear understanding of the role of microbial communities in regulating ecosystem functions such as coral growth rates, nutrient availability, and overall metabolic budgets. Topics that would be relevant in this session include interactions between microbes and coral reef organic matter, microbial transformations of nutrients, microbiome influences on host physiology relevant at the ecosystem scale, contributions of microbial biomass to reef food webs, or 'omics-informed ecological investigations of specific microbial populations/communities involved in biogeochemical cycling.
Claudia Pogoreutz1, Anny Cárdenas1, Raquel Peixoto2, Till Röthig3
1 KAUST (Thuwal, Saudi Arabia)
2 Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (Rio de Janeiro, Brazil)
3 University of Derby (Derby, UK)
Although reef-building corals and other reef organisms are increasingly recognized as holobionts, we have limited understanding of how associated microorganisms interact with their eukaryotic hosts, with each other, and with their environment. Mounting evidence suggests that host-associated microorganisms other than Symbiodiniaeae may be central to both resilience and degradation of coral reefs. Hence, to obtain a better understanding of key coral reef holobionts, it will be paramount to integrate functional approaches to reef microbiology. Specifically, several issues are of interest: 1) the identification and quantification of microbial metabolic traits in key reef holobionts, 2) mechanistic approaches to resolve microbial metabolic contribution to holobiont functioning, and 3) operationalizing microbiome manipulations, i.e. employ microorganisms and/or microbial consortia to enhance benefitial holobiont traits (‘marine probiotics’). Addressing these issues will be critical for an integrated understanding of the reef ecosystem, and may offer new venues for innovative management approaches. We invite oral and poster contributions using interdisciplinary approaches aiming at either functionality that explains the mechanistic underpinnings of holobiont-microbiome associations or their modification to boost holobiont resilience. Such approaches may include established ecophysiological techniques, combining next-generation “omics” and high-resolution imaging techniques, or microbiome manipulations and marine probiotics and their potential application in conservation and restoration. The goal of this session is to communicate most recent advances, challenges, and perspectives in exploring symbioses on coral reefs, and to provide a forum for collaboration and exchange.
Amy Apprill 1, Koty Sharp2, Tracy Ainsworth3
1 Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (Woods Hole, MA, USA)
2 Roger Williams University (Rhode Island, USA)
3 The University of New South Wales (Sydney, Australia)
Microorganisms are associated with diverse protist and animal life on reefs and these microbial communities or microbiomes play important roles in the health, ecology and even behavior of their hosts. Recent advances in sequencing, microscopy and other technological approaches have provided opportunities to examine host-associated microbiomes in-depth, providing glimpses into patterns of microbial diversity, community composition as well as the location and specific symbiotic nature of microorganisms associated with reefs and reef-dwelling hosts. With this new wealth of knowledge brings an opportunity to understand the defining patterns governing these relationships among diverse hosts, environments and experimental conditions, which may provide novel insights into host-microbiome interactions. At the same time there is also an opportunity to learn from disparate host-microbiome patterns, which may be central to understanding specific organismal or environmental adaptations. The goal of this session is to bring together microbiome studies across diverse hosts (protists, corals, fish, invertebrates, etc.), representing disparate reef environments (tropical, temperate, cold and deep water) as well as within the context of natural or induced experimental conditions (e.g., temperature stress, ocean acidification, disease, macroalgal exposure, etc.). As a scientific community and throughout the session, we will compare, contrast and discuss what is similar and distinct in microbiome diversity, community structure and defining taxa within these studies, with the overarching goal of shedding new light on governing principles of host-microbiome relationships and advancing our understanding of how those host-microbiome relationships respond to environmental change on reefs.
Brian Walker 1, Karen Neely1, Erinn Muller2, Josh Voss3, Greta Aeby4
1 Nova Southeastern University (Fort Lauderdale, Fl, USA)
2 Mote Marine Laboratory (Sarasota, FL, USA)
3 Florida Atlantic University (Boca Raton, FL, USA)
5 Qatar University (Qatar)
Outbreaks of coral diseases are expected to become more frequent and severe from a combination of chronic local stress (overfishing, land-based pollution) and global climate change. The first step in mitigating damage from disease outbreaks is an understanding of the underlying disease processes. Concomitantly, there is an urgent need to develop field intervention techniques, disease response plans, and engage citizen scientists in these efforts. Efforts to understand, control, or mitigate these outbreaks may be challenging, but can be considered at the lesion, colony, reef, or landscape level. Efforts should be collaborative involving researchers, managers, and community members. This session aims to convene international reef scientists and managers who have, or anticipate having to respond to disease outbreaks, and invites them to present the latest coral disease research, intervention approaches and, response plan success and failures. Regions throughout the world are facing the problems with disease outbreaks and sharing "lessons learned" can help researchers and managers address this growing problem.
Ernesto Weil 1, Caroline Rogers2, Aldo Croquer3, Laurie Raymundo4, Joleah Lamb5, Greta Aeby 6, Beatriz Casareto7
1 University of Puerto Rico (Mayaguez, Puerto Rico)
2 US Geological Survey (St. John, US Virgin Islands)
3 Dept. Estudios Ambientales (Caracas, Venezuela)
4 University of Guam (Mangilao, Guam)
5 University of California (Irvine, CA, USA)
6 Qatar University (Qatar)
7 Shizuoka University (Shizuoka, Japan)
Marine ecosystems, from the temperate zones to the tropics and from the shore down to mesophotic depths (40-150m), are being exposed to increasing seawater temperatures and overall water quality deterioration. Mounting evidence has confirmed severe global degradation of tropical and temperate coral, octocoral, sea-grass and rocky-shore ecosystems. Mass mortality events documented over the last four decades, impacting foundation and/or keystone species in these important communities are mostly linked to large thermal anomalies associated with Global Climate Change (GCC). Heat accumulation then triggers bleaching and outbreaks of new and old diseases, and their synergistic effects, producing the mortalities. Overall, the ecological integrity of the affected communities degrades, affecting structure, function, diversity, and the ecological services they provide. The study of coral reef disease began as a novel science 48 years ago, and significant advances have been made in many areas (pathology, etiology, epizootiology and immunology). Nevertheless, there are still open discussions on terminology, best epizootiological approaches, lagging pathological molecular and studies, geographic distributions, diagnostic signs, short vs. long temporal observations, amongst other topics. This session is intended as a venue to summarize the last four-to-five decades of research on marine diseases, with emphasis on coral reefs and other key coastal communities. We encourage presentations that summarize major findings and advances in studies of marine diseases, including topics such as holobiont dynamics and disease, pathogen variability and dynamics, role of bacteria, fungi, viruses and other parasites, local and exotic pathogens, etc. We also encourage submissions that advance the study and documentation of the ecological, economic and sociological impacts of disease, such as mass mortalities, geographic patterns, spatial and temporal variability of persistent diseases vs. seasonal outbreaks, environmental and human-induced drivers, and continuing challenges to research. We hope to produce a review manuscript as a product of this session, summarizing the major topics and progress, what we have learned, the major challenges and limitations and how these can be addressed.
Koty Sharp 1, Sean Grace2, Hanny Rivera3, Randi Rotjan3, Sam Vohsen4
1 Roger Williams University (Bristol, RI, USA)
2 Southern Connecticut State University (New Haven, CT, USA)
3 Boston University (Boston, MA, USA)
4 Pennsylvania State University (State College, PA, USA)
Global change, and the resultant disruption of symbiosis and mass bleaching, is threatening coral reef ecosystems worldwide. Recent research efforts have identified several cnidarian species with broad thermal ranges and/or variable states of symbiosis with Symbiodiniaceae as excellent model systems for addressing specific questions about the ecology and physiology of coral symbiosis. Some of these species, including calcifying corals of the genera Astrangia and Oculina, and the anemones Nematostella and Aiptasia, are rapidly improving our understanding of symbiotic interactions, elucidating how relationships between cnidarian hosts and their microbiomes (including prokaryotes, fungi, Symbiodiniaceae, etc.) influence bleaching, calcification, growth, behavior, nutrition, reproduction, immune response, and thermal adaptation. These model systems allow the disentanglement of host and symbiont processes that drive response and resilience to environmental change. The aim of this session is to explore how cnidarian model systems can inform our understanding of symbiosis in the coral holobiont and the factors that drive dysbiosis, leading to tropical coral decline. We encourage submissions that utilize temperate, facultatively symbiotic, asymbiotic, and/or cold-water cnidarians to address these questions from the host, symbiont, or holobiont perspective. This session offers a platform for the recently formalized collaborative groups centered on emerging model cnidarian systems, but also for a broader audience of reef researchers interested in re-examining the fundamentals of coral symbiosis biology.
William Fitt 1, Aki Ohdera2, Monica Medina3, Dietrich Hofmann4
1 University of Georgia (Athens, GA, USA)
2 Carnegie Institute (Baltimore, MD, USA)
3 Pennsylvania State University (State College, PA, USA)
4 Ruhr-Universität (Bochum, Germany)
The upside-down jellyfish (Cassiopea xamachana) is an emerging model system to study cnidarian-algal-microbial symbiosis. A growing Cassiopea scientific community is not only addressing symbiosis-related questions using a broad range of approaches from molecular to the organismal level, but are utilizing the system for behavioral, ecological, and environmental inquiries. The life cycle of the jellyfish is now well established in multiple laboratories around the world, the genome has been sequenced and genetic tools are in development. Knowledge of the biology of microbial partners (e.g. settlement-inducing bacteria, strobilation-inducing Symbiodinacea) that interact with this animal host is also increasing, again with genomic and genetic manipulation also in the horizon. The enhanced experimental potential, broad application outside of cnidarian biology, and relative low cost implementation of this system, deserve a venue at the ISRS meeting such that laboratories, especially in developing nations, can learn and take advantage of the research possibilities Cassiopea provides to study topics such as environmental monitoring, ecoloigcal interactions, evolutionary development, evolution of behavior, and as a proxy to study onset and breakdown (e.g. bleaching) of coral-algal symbiosis.
Christian R. Voolstra1, Peter J. Schupp2, Rebecca Vega Thurber3, Tilmann Harder 4
1 University of Konstanz (Konstanz, Germany)
2 University of Oldenburg (Oldenburg, Germany)
3 Oregon State University (Corvallis, OR, USA)
4 University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 4 that do not feel addressed by the above specialized sessions.
Corals are a diverse group of large organisms which provide important habitat not only in tropical shallow water systems, but also in deep and cold-water and higher latitudes. Important aspects of the biology and ecology of cold-water and temperate corals and their associated communities are still only poorly understood. This theme session invites contributions from all disciplines relating to cold-water and temperate reefs. Preference will be given to topics and themes not covered by the special sessions.
Andrea Gori1, Covadonga Orejas2, Erik Cordes3, Furu Mienis4, Marina Carreiro-Silva 5, Murray Roberts6, Sebastian Hennige6
1 Università del Salento (Lecce, Italy)
2 Instituto Español de Oceanografía (Palma de Mallorca, Spain)
3 Temple University (Philadelphia, USA)
4 NIOZ & Utrecht University (Texel, The Netherlands)
5 Universidade dos Açores (Horta, Portugal)
6 University of Edinburgh (Edinburgh, United Kingdom)
Scleractinian corals and gorgonians are among the main ecosystem engineers in the deep-sea, generating complex three-dimensional habitats characterized by high abundance and diversity of associated species, comparable to tropical and temperate shallow coral reefs. Cold-water coral reefs and coral gardens are distributed globally and have been exposed to substantial anthropogenic pressures like fishing, oil and gas exploration and global change. In recent years, knowledge of these ecosystems has greatly increased. This session will present the most recent advances in our knowledge of cold-water coral ecology and conservation including: (1) the discovery, mapping and characterization of cold-water coral reefs and coral gardens ecosystems, (2) the ecological and eco-physiological processes in these ecosystems, (3) the threats and their effects on these fragile ecosystems, and (4) the last advances in their restoration, management and conservation. We expect this session to be especially interesting for the scientific community focused on the research about cold-water coral reefs and coral gardens in the deep-sea, but also for all the scientific community generally working on coral ecology, management and conservation. We expect this session to allow significantly increasing the scientific collaboration between these two scientific communities, which are traditionally limited despite the many similarities in research lines and methods.
Erik Caroselli 1, Nuria Teixido2, Jaap Kaandorp3, Zvy Dubinsky4, Stefano Goffredo1
1 University of Bologna (Bologna, Italy)
2 Sorbonne Université, CNRS (Villefranche-sur-Mer, France)
3 University of Amsterdam (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
4 Bar Ilan University (Ramat-Gan, Israel)
While most studies about the impact of climate change on marine ecosystems focus on tropical regions, knowledge about the impacts on temperate reefs is relatively scarce. Nevertheless, temperate areas host biodiversity hotspots (e.g. the Mediterranean Sea) and are projected to be severely impacted by climate change. During the last two decades, research on the impact of climate change on temperate biota has been performed with experiment in controlled conditions, mesocosms, and "natural laboratories", such as those found at some volcanic carbon dioxide vents or along natural temperature gradients. Some of these peculiar natural settings have been discovered in temperate regions and represent a unique opportunity for climate change-related studies. This session focuses on the impacts of various aspects of climate change (e.g. seawater warming, acidification, and deoxygenation, sea level rise, increased frequency of extreme events) on temperate species, ecosystems, and regions and how they relate to the expected impacts in tropical regions.
Claudio Richter1, Covadonga Orejas 2, Gertraud M. Schmidt-Grieb 1
1 AWI Bremerhaven (Bremerhaven, Germany)
2 Instituto Español de Oceanografía (Palma de Mallorca, Spain)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 5 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Many coral reefs in the world have been studied extensively. Coral reefs that remain relatively underexplored are those located in remote, hardly accessible locations and those that have recently been discovered in unexpected environments. The latter include mesophotic reefs, reefs exposed to extreme temperatures such as the reefs in the Persian Arabian Gulf, reefs exposed to high riverine input such as the recently discovered reef in the Amazon Delta and reefs in intertidal habitats. Reefs at remote and unexpected locations may host hitherto unknown reservoirs of genetic resources that may play a role in preserving coral reefs in an era of rapid change. Theme 6 welcomes presentations that relate to reefs at remote and unexpected locations and to the potential role of these reefs in coral conservation.
Marc Slattery1, Frederic Sinniger2, Gal Eyal3, Tyler Smith4, Kimberly Puglise5, Alejandra Hernandez6
1 University of Mississippi (Oxford, MS, USA)
2 University of Ryukyus (Sesoko, Japan)
3 The University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
4 University of the Virgin Islands (St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands)
5 NOAA National Ocean Service (Silver Spring, MD, USA)
6 California Academy of Sciences (San Francisco, CA, USA)
Research on mesophotic coral ecosystems (MCEs: ~30-150 m depth) has increased exponentially over the past decade. Increasing interest has been driven in large part by the “Deep Reef Refugia” hypothesis that suggests MCEs are less susceptible to the disturbances faced by nearby shallow coral reefs (e.g., coral bleaching, diseases, overfishing, and land-based pollution), and, through larval connectivity, could serve as potential “Lifeboats” for shallow reefs. As we address the challenging future of coral reefs, MCEs will clearly be an important topic, and assessing their role in the larger context of coral reefs requires addressing their basic ecological, physiological, and oceanographic processes. From this we can contextualize the origin and evolution of MCE flora and fauna relative to shallow reefs. This session will highlight recent research on MCEs from multiple perspectives such as: Biodiversity, Community structure and dynamics, Population connectivity, Biology of MCE organisms, and Geological and physical processes. Through this interdisciplinary approach, the session will explore both the similarities and differences of MCEs in comparison to shallow reefs, as well as conservation and remediation of MCEs in order to understand their roles as “Lifeboats”. Our goal is to increase the dialog with coral scientists focused on shallow reefs to improve our understanding of the complete coral ecosystem, and to tackle these, and other research priorities, in the context of the challenging future of coral reefs.
Emma Camp1, Jessica Bellworthy 2, Nadia Santodomingo3, Eslam O. Osman4, Guilhem Banc-Prandi 2, Verena Schoepf 5
1 University of Technology Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
2 Interuniversity Institute for Marine Science (Eilat, Israel)
3 Natural History Museum (London, UK)
4 Pennsylvania State University (Pennsylvania, PA, USA)
5 The University of Western Australia (Perth, Australia)
Rapid environmental change is compromising coral reefs globally, requiring enhanced knowledge on which habitats will be more likely to serve as coral refugia. Insights gained by studying geographic locations of stress tolerant corals (e.g. the northern Red Sea) and those in marginal and extreme coral habitats that house corals living under suboptimal environmental conditions (e.g. mesophotic reefs, latitudinal extremes, inter-tidal-habitats, turbid reefs, and reef-neighbouring habitats –including up-welling, mangrove habitats, seagrass and CO2 vent sites), can be used to better manage such sites and aid coral reef resilience. Research into these locations are revealing novel habitat functions, including refuge capacity, preconditioning to climate change, and stocks of genetic biodiversity. Furthermore, studies on the traits and physiological mechanisms of individuals from these habitats are showing the adaptive and/or acclimatory processes required to survive stress. Thus, these systems are providing unique natural laboratories to enhance our understanding of coral survival under suboptimal conditions, while accounting for timescales of long-term acclimatisation, adaptation and local community reorganisation to the prevailing conditions. In this session, we seek to attract a diverse range of abstracts that contribute new knowledge on refugia, extreme and marginal coral habitats and their reef associated taxa to: i) further our understanding of how environmental conditions contribute to novel ecosystem services for resident populations, and to ii) enhance our understanding of the acclimation/adaptation mechanisms that facilitate survival. Collectively the session will seek to advance our knowledge of the location, vulnerabilities and value of reef refugia, while advancing our knowledge of the mechanisms that facilitate survival of resident populations.
Stuart Sandin 1, Mark Vermeij2, Jennifer Smith1, Gareth Williams3
1 Scripps Institution of Oceanography (La Jolla, CA, USA)
2 CARMABI / University of Amsterdam (Curacao / The Netherlands)
3 Bangor University (Bangor, UK)
Recent efforts have sought to describe in detail the decline of reef structure, using the diversity and species composition of little-impacted reefs as a reference for 'pristine' or 'baseline'. One approach to management is to strive toward returning impacted reefs back toward these baselines. In many locations, however, there is little chance of 're-wilding' reefs to historic conditions due to the ongoing needs and impacts of human populations (i.e., fishing, shoreline use, climate shifts). A complementary form of management is to target improved functioning of reef communities to provide improvements and sustainability in the services provided to local populations. A growing number of case studies are emerging of well-functioning coral reefs being found in unexpected locations. Extreme examples include thriving coral growth in outflow plumes from power plants, clear and microbe-light waters adjacent to poorly maintained sewage systems, and extremely productive reef fisheries on heavily populated islands. Observational data from across the variety of coral reef contexts assists us in learning about the variation and potential of reef communities to adapt to changing environmental conditions. This session calls to the coral reef community to share case studies of reefs showing strength in unexpected locations. The goal will be to find generalities in the case studies to guide practical management looking forward.
Ronald Osinga1, Gert Wörheide2, Cecilia D’Angelo3
1 Wageningen University (Wageningen, The Netherlands)
2 LMU München (München, Germany)
3 University of Southampton (Southampton, UK)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 6 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Coral reef are profusely biodiverse ecosystems with complex spatial and community structural patterns. The dense tapestry of taxonomic variety, topographic complexity and specific adaptations poses challenges to a reductionist study of reef systems. Our scales of observation, analysis and explanation need to span the range from cellular or organism level to regional and biogeographic levels. This requires innovative developments of technology, methodology, data acquisition and analysis as a means to scale up observations across scales of reef system function. Theme 7 welcomes contributions that relate to scaling up our observations of reef organisms and systems, improving analytical throughput, cross-disciplinary efforts and reaching new levels of explanations of system function.
David Souter 1, David Obura2, Serge Planes3, Supin Wongbusarakum4
1 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
2 CORDIO East Africa (Mombasa, Kenya)
3 CRIOBE (Moorea, French Polynesia)
4 NOAA Pacific Island Fisheries Science Center (Honolulu, HI, USA)
Despite the unquestionable value of coral reefs to local communities, national economies and global biodiversity, there has been a steady worldwide decline in their condition as a result of increasing local to global pressures. Prevention of further degradation and maintenance of resilience within these critical ecosystems is dependent on understanding the interdependence of reefs and people, and the implementation of appropriate and timely management actions. The foundation for such knowledge is gained through the implementation of targeted long-term and integrated monitoring programs. The Global Coral Reef Monitoring Network (GCRMN) is an operational network of the International Coral Reef Initiative (ICRI), and a worldwide network of coral reef scientists, managers, and organisations. Since its establishment in 1995, the GCRMN has produced five Status of Coral Reefs of the World reports between 1998 and 2008. These reports have had significant impact within the global scientific, NGO, government and United Nations (UN) communities, with the UN recognising GCRMN's significant role in monitoring progress toward coral reef-related Aichi Biodiversity Targets (Target 10) and Sustainable Development Goals (13 & 14). In response to calls by ICRI members, a new GCRMN Implementation and Governance Plan has been adopted, with an initial focus on the next Status of Coral Reefs of the World report. The report will be launched at ICRS 2020, and this mini-symposium will inform conference participants and a global audience of the current status of the world's coral reefs, the major threats they face, their socio-economic importance, and the initiatives being implemented to manage and conserve these critical ecosystems. This session welcomes contributions presenting long-term surveys of coral reefs, integrated datasets and innovative monitoring tools to promote greater collaboration and magnification of monitoring consistent with the UN Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainability.
Alexander Venn 1, Sylvie Tambutté1, Anton Eisenhauer2, Virginie Chamard3
1 Centre Scientifique de Monaco (Monaco)
2 GEOMAR (Kiel, Germany)
3 Institut Fresnel (Marseille, France)
Calcification is the process by which tiny coral polyps build the largest bioconstructions on the planet, the coral reefs. Despite the biological and geochemical importance of calcification and more than 100 years of investigation, our understanding of this process and its underlying mechanism still remains patchy. Calcification is sensitive to many aspects of global environmental change, and improving understanding of calcification is the key to a clearer vision of how coral reefs responded to past environmental change and how they will fare in future decades. Contemporary research on calcification is breaking exciting, new ground in diverse disciplines such as biochemistry, physiology, material design and paleogeochemistry. Such studies address different levels of organization from the biomineral to the organism. To push the frontiers of understanding, new innovative approaches are being used to improve the culturing of biological material from cell to colony, and in the analysis of calcification processes. Among these are molecular and proteomic approaches; physiological techniques such as Ussing chambers, microelectrodes and in vivo confocal imaging; and geochemical or material science techniques including Raman spectroscopy, secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS), nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR), cryo-scanning electron microscopy (SEM), laser-ablation techniques and synchrotron based x-ray diffraction or scattering microscopy. This session welcomes presentations that concern investigations applying these and other innovative approaches with or without classical techniques (buoyant weight, alkalinity anomaly, radioactive isotopes) that show the potential to shed new light into the processes driving calcification and growth. Description of the advantages and drawbacks/limitations of the techniques are also welcome. Corals are the focus of this session, however we also welcome presentations concerning other calcifying organisms associated with coral reefs.
Phillip A. Cleves 1, Katie Barott2
1 Stanford University (San Francisco, CA, USA)
2 University of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia, PA, USA)
A major goal of coral biology is to better understand the genetic and cell-biological bases of how cnidarian-dinoflagellate symbioses are established and maintained, and how they break down under stress. Such an understanding would provide a solid foundation for attempts to mitigate the effects of stress and promote coral-reef conservation. In recent years, modern sequencing technologies have led to an abundance of transcriptomic and genomic studies of corals, which have resulted in many intriguing hypotheses about the mechanisms of interest. However, these hypotheses need rigorous testing before they can contribute reliably to conservation efforts. This session will focus on the latest advances in our understanding of cnidarian cell biology, including the major technological developments that are contributing to our ability to experimentally test these hypotheses. First, the development of model systems, such as the small sea anemone Aiptasia, the upside-down jellyfish Cassiopea, and coral cell culture, has allowed studies that would be difficult or impossible in corals themselves. Second, the application of advanced microscopy methods to the cell biology of cnidarian symbioses has facilitated examination of in vivo dynamics and micro-scale interactions. Third, and particularly revolutionary in its potential, is the application of new genetic methods, such as those based on CRISPR/Cas9, which enable generation of mutants that allow for rigorous examination of gene and protein function. The session will attempt to summarize both the state of the art in regard to the relevant technologies and the progress in biological understanding that has been made to date by applying these technologies.
Josh Levy1, Carlie Wiener2, Phil McGillivary 3, Ved Chirayath4
1 University of Hawaii (Honolulu, HI, USA),
2 Schmidt Ocean Institute (Palo Alto, CA, USA)
3 US Coast Guard Pacific Area Science Liaison (Alameda, CA, USA)
4 NASA Ames Research Lab (Moffett Field, CA, USA)
Traditionally, coral research and ecosystem monitoring activities involve the use of conventional diver surveys for shallow reef systems, and research ships with submersible vehicles for mesophotic and deep reefs. High costs of diver and ship operations, and their inability to support long-term persistent observations due to endurance constraints, weather limitations, and diver safety, emphasize the need for more cost-efficient and scalable alternatives. To address the monetary and time challenges of reef research and monitoring, we need to reduce the cost of obtaining data at biologically relevant spatial and temporal scales. Proposed solutions include using unmanned systems, data fusion, analytics, and visualization techniques to collect and process data for use by both science and conservation communities. Unmanned technologies have the ability to collect data over large areas at a low personnel and monetary cost, and disseminate data in near real time, making them increasingly useful assets for reef management. This session will focus on emerging technologies to support coral research and ecosystem monitoring with improved operational scale, coverage, resolution, and cost-efficiency. The session will assess robotic and software innovations, data fusion/processing, visualization techniques, intelligent data use for reef studies, and how to accelerate their adoption by ocean scientists and ecosystem managers. Session topics may include effective applications of innovative robotic survey, monitoring, mapping, and interactive research platforms, such as autonomous aerial, surface, and underwater vehicles, and other remote sensing methodologies. Also of interest are adaptive survey techniques involving analytical decision support, cross-platform coordination and communication, and how intelligent data use can increase operational efficiency of robotic marine surveys.
Emma Gibbin 1, Philippe Laissue2
1 École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (Lausanne, Switzerland)
2 University of Essex (Colchester, UK)
Our better understanding of the cellular processes underlying the biology of reef organisms and the dynamics within their communities depends on the ability to image their morphology and composition over time and at high spatial resolution. Imaging calcifying organisms such as corals however, is complicated by their opaque aragonite skeleton, the complex microtopography of the surface and the difference in scale that exists between the many symbiotic partners that form the holobiont. Traditional analytical techniques have relied on the physical separation of the main components– calcified skeleton, coral tissue and symbionts. Such approaches 1) preclude observation of dynamic host-symbiont or host-pathogen interactions, and 2) lose all information about the spatial distribution of compounds within tissues and cells. The first limitation can be overcome by non-invasive, live imaging techniques such as light-sheet fluorescence microscopy, optical coherence tomography, and/or digital holographic microscopy. Importantly, live imaging can be combined with other powerful in situ techniques such as microfluidics and micro-electrodes, which enables the observation and measurement of in vivo morphological, behavioural and physiological responses of an organism to environmental stress (e.g. enhanced mucus production prior to bleaching, zooxanthellar expulsion in response to stress, and mesenterial filament dynamics in wound repair and pathogenicity). The second constraint can be overcome using high spatial resolution molecular imaging techniques such as nano-scale secondary-ion mass spectrometry (NanoSIMS) and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI-MSI), which, when combined with stable isotopes, enables the quantification and/or identification of the flux of metabolites in an intact symbiosis. Live- and molecular imaging techniques are in fact, highly complementary, and the combination of the two has the potential to help answer some of the most fundamental questions remaining in coral reef research: how does the coral immune system function? What is the tipping point for the transition between health and disease? And, how will the coral holobiont respond to multiple stressors in the face of climate change? The techniques presented here are not limited only to coral. They can also be used to probe the composition of- and dynamics between different species within coral reef communities, from crustose coralline algae and cyanobacteria to microbiomes and the coral holobiont. In this session, we invite leading scientists to showcase their latest results and present the advantages of new imaging approaches. We encourage speakers to emphasise practical aspects, with the intention to stimulate usage of the showcased technique for addressing new biological questions.
David Miller 1, Ira Cooke1, Chris Voolstra2, Iliana Baums 3
1 James Cook University (Townsville, Australia)
2 University of Konstanz (Konstanz, Germany)
3 Pennsylvania State University (Pennsylvania, PA, USA)
The ever-decreasing cost of high throughput sequencing technologies and their wide application outside of the traditional model organisms has enabled rapid progress in, and new perspectives on, many aspects of the biology of reef organisms, from corals to fish. This session will highlight novel findings from genomic, transcriptomic and metagenomic analyses of reef organisms, and the symbiotic interactions between various components of reef holobionts.
Robert Richmond 1, Kaho Tisthammer2, Narrissa Spies3
1 University of Hawaii at Manoa (Honolulu, HI, USA)
2 San Francisco State University (San Francisco, CA, USA)
3 Pacific Islands Fish and Wildlife Office (Honolulu, HI, USA)
In a world of continuing and accelerating coral reef losses, it is essential to determine the key stressors, their thresholds, and combined effects in order to design, implement and evaluate the effectiveness of appropriate interventions. Ecological approaches largely rely on correlation to determine relationships among multiple stressors and the effects on coral reef ecosystems, and it takes months, years and decades to measure many responses and trends. Molecular tools, including proteomics, genomics, metabolomics and transcriptomics, can identify true cause-and-effect relationships between stressors and responses over shorter time periods, from hours, to days and weeks. They can also be used to identify and quantify changes tied to stressor exposure in organisms on the reef and under controlled laboratory conditions. As molecular tools are further refined and associated costs decrease, it is now possible and practical to include these in coral reef assessment and monitoring programs. It is also possible to determine threshold stressor levels that result in impairment of functions such as reproduction, or result in outright mortality. This session is organized to include researchers studying organisms across coral reef taxa, resource managers who could use these data to guide interventions, stakeholders affected by coral reef losses, and policy makers who can apply such information to develop effective legislation to improve the effective allocation of limited human, institutional and financial resources to address and reverse the present downward trajectory of coral reefs. The intention of this session is to highlight the latest research, address how such studies can be applied to supporting coral reef persistence, resilience and restoration, and address key information gaps and management challenges.
Emma Kennedy 1, Chris Roelfsema1, Sarah Hamylton2, Stuart Phinn1, Greg Asner 3
1 University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
2 University of Wollongong (New South Wales, Australia)
3 Arizona State University (Tempe AZ and Hilo HI, USA)
Advances in technologies to measure, map, model and monitor reefs from polyp to global scales, and integrate across a wide range of different data sets and disciplines have facilitated expansive work to scale-up reef research. More rapid data acquisition, better mechanisms for data sharing, and a growing community of reef scientists has allowed better and broader collaborations, from pooling global bleaching observations to citizen science monitoring. Many of the current challenges faced by reefs - including overfishing and climate change - are global in their nature. Some of our datasets, collaborations and tools are becoming more global too. What lessons have we learned from expanding our reach beyond the confines of disciplinary and geographical boundaries? This session aims to be highly interdisciplinary and welcomes submissions from any studies that seek to upscale their observations and findings, from macroecology, biogeography, earth systems monitoring, oceanography, conservation planning, social science and mapping global change and beyond!
Arjun Chennu 1, Manuel Gonzalez Rivero 2
1 MPI Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
2 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 7 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Coral reefs are not only a marine biodiversity hotspot inhabited by a vast range of species, but are also a vital basis for the livelihood for millions of people. Human uses of reefs date back more than 100,000 years, and human societies have developed deep and complex relationships with reefs that go beyond extractive uses including highly diverse fisheries, and entail rich cultural traditions, cosmologies and detailed ecological knowledge. Modern uses of reefs include a billion-dollar tourism industry, and attempts to quantify the services reefs provide to society e.g. in terms of coastal protection mean that their high economic value is increasingly recognized. Recent decades have seen a resurging interest in traditional and modern human relationships with reefs, for example as sources of ecological information, in the description of cultural diversity, as part of ecosystem valuations, or to identify and develop sustainable forms of utilizing reefs. Theme 8 welcomes presentations that look into the various kinds of relations humans have with coral reefs.
Annet Pauwelussen1, Aída Sofía Rivera Sotelo2
1 Wageningen University (Wageningen, The Netherlands)
2 University of California, Davis (Davis, CA, USA)
In recent years people from a range of disciplines and societal backgrounds have joined discussions and practices of coral protection and rehabilitation. The precarious state of coral reefs is becoming a matter of concern not only to natural scientists and conservationists but also anthropologists, artists, fishers, and entrepreneurs, among others. Increasingly, inter- and transdisciplinary alliances are built to aim for forms of coral care that is effective, socially just and receptive to diverse ways of knowing and relating to corals. As a consequence, coral protection and rehabilitation programs bring together different ways in which people know, define, value and imagine corals and care. How can we understand and make sense of such complexity? How may alliances be built that allow for dialogues on how to care for corals in collaboration? The social sciences could engage theoretically and empirically with concepts, theories, methods and storytelling helping to establish dialogues across difference. Taking inspiration from recent currents in anthropology, Science and Technology Studies and social geography, among others, possible questions to explore are: What and how are the corals we care for? How do we think and imagine their pasts and futures? How is this informed by the conditions of our disciplines, our field sites, or our basic notions of reality and ethics? And how does this affect the kinds of care, management, conservation and rehabilitation measures that are elicited into future reefs? Who gets to care for corals and at expense of what other forms of caring? This panel calls for proposals that think about these questions, through theoretical contribution, methodological reflection and case studies.
Sebastian Ferse1, Christina Hicks2, Colette Wabnitz3
1 Leibniz Center for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 Lancaster University (Lancaster, UK)
3 The University of British Columbia (Vancouver, Canada)
This open session invites all contributions that relate to Theme 8.
Coral reefs worldwide have become the poster child for ecological casualties of the Anthropocene, via impacts from global-scale (climate change) and local (urbanisation, agriculture and fisheries) stressors. Complex interactions amongst these stressors continually re-shape reef form and functioning, resulting in ever-shifting baselines for ecosystem service provision. Implementing meaningful strategies to secure the future of coral reefs rests on rapidly improving understanding of how complex stress scenarios affect reef biota and ecologies, but also on developing effective management practices to mitigate or absorb stressors. This theme covers coral reef science in its entirety, from fundamental biology and ecology to governance and policy development, to examine: How do global versus local stressors impact coral reefs? How do stressors interact to affect the outcome of biological, ecological and/or socio-economic trajectories? What are the key knowledge gaps that must be urgently addressed to better predict how multi-stressor impacts affect reefs over space and time?
Katharina Fabricius 1, Joy Smith1, Rebecca Albright2
1 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
2 California Academy of Sciences (San Francisco, CA, USA)
Ocean acidification is an insidious and chronic stressor for coral reefs that can be enhanced in coastal waters. In coastal regions and on shallow continental shelves, a number of processes including eutrophication can further elevate CO2, leading to coastal acidification. Many coral reefs are therefore exposed to both ocean and coastal acidification. While ocean acidification is irreversible at human time scales, coastal acidification may be more amenable to management via water quality improvement strategies. To date, much work has focused on the effects of acidification on future reefs under various CO2 emission scenarios. Evidence now suggests that some of today's coral reefs are already being substantially altered by these changes in seawater carbonate chemistry. Carbon dioxide dynamics in coral reefs are controlled by high intrinsic rates of production, respiration and calcification, as well as by imports of nutrients and organic matter from external sources, light, and by light and seawater hydrodynamics. Together, these factors expose coral reefs to highly variable and at times extreme carbonate chemistry conditions. This session will bring together new insights into the relevant biophysical drivers and processes of ocean and coastal acidification, and their measured and predicted consequences for present and future coral reef ecosystems. We invite studies focusing on this portfolio of questions, with emphasis on carbonate chemistry variability and trends, on conceptual and empirical findings on their effects ranging from molecular to ecosystems, and on research methods development ranging from biochemical to modelling.
Heather Page 1, Kristen Brown 2, Tyler Cyronak3, Keisha Bahr4, Robert Nowicki1
1 Mote Marine Laboratory (Summerland Key, FL, USA)
2 University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
3 Nova Southeastern University (Dania Beach, FL, USA)
4 Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology (Kaneohe, HI, USA)
Global anthropogenic change threatens the ability of coral reefs to maintain ecosystem structure and function. Thermal stress events leading to mass coral bleaching are becoming more frequent and severe on tropical coral reefs while ocean acidification is projected to intensify, impacting the ability of reefs to calcify and maintain net calcium carbonate accretion. Traditionally, studies have focused on understanding the response of individual reef organisms to environmental change. While these species-level studies provide valuable information, there is a growing need to focus our efforts on ecosystem-level dynamics to better understand the effects of anthropogenic change on the structure, function, and recovery of coral reefs from a systems perspective. This session invites presentations that focus on the effects of environmental change on coral reef populations, communities, and/or ecosystems. These studies can include a range of approaches including: (i) mesocosm and in situ experimental studies, (ii) techniques such as eddy covariance and benthic boundary layer approaches that can enhance our understanding of community level function in situ, (iii) observations of community structure and ecosystem function across natural environmental gradients (i.e., carbon dioxide seeps) and thermal stress events, (iv) ecosystem models, or (v) innovative approaches to scaling up coral reef research across ecologically relevant scales. Research efforts at the scale of populations, communities, and ecosystems will help build more realistic representations of the environmental tolerances of coral reefs in the future. This new knowledge can then be used to identify the most effective policies, management strategies, and conservation techniques for the maintenance and recovery of reef ecosystem function into the future.
Jessica Reichert1, Maren Ziegler1, Mia Hoogenboom2
1 Justus Liebig University (Giessen, Germany)
2 James Cook University (Townsville, Australia)
Tropical reef systems are rapidly transitioning to an era of increasing anthropogenic impacts. In particular, the pollution with plastic material has been identified as an emerging threat to coral reefs. Growing quantities of large plastic objects wash up on tropical shores and also affect coastal marine organisms. In addition, these large plastic objects undergo fragmentation into micro- and nanoplastic particles in exponential quantities. However, little is known about plastic concentrations of different sizes and types in reef ecosystems and their consequences for the organisms inhabiting coral reefs. More thorough observations of plastic distribution patterns in time and space are needed to understand this rapidly developing threat to coral reefs. Further, impact assessment studies addressing the biological consequences for reef organisms are necessary to evaluate the potential impact of plastic pollution and to estimate its interactive effects with other anthropogenic stressors. This requires broad assessment of the organisms' responses to plastics under realistic or projected pollution levels. This session aims to set up a platform for discussion of the potential hazards of plastic pollution from the macro- to the micro- and nanoscale. We invite contributions from diverse fields including biology, oceanography, and chemistry that document and quantify plastic pollution in coral reef organisms and their surrounding environment, as well as experimental approaches that investigate the biological responses of coral reef organisms to plastic pollution. The overarching aim of this session is to provide a synthesis of past and perspective on future research priorities on plastic pollution in coral reefs.
Deron Burkepile1, Nina Schiettekatte2, Sébastien Villéger3, Jacob Allgeier4
1 University of California Santa Barbara (Santa Barbara, CA, USA)
2 Université de Perpignan (Perpignan, France)
3 Université de Montpellier (Montpellier, France)
4 University of Michigan (Ann Arbor, MI, USA)
Coral reefs are highly productive, biodiversity hotspots. Ever since the first descriptions of reefs by Charles Darwin, scientists have pondered over how such a productive system can thrive in an oligotrophic environment. One key to ecosystem function on reefs appears to be a very efficient recycling of nutrients by reef-dwelling animals such as fishes, sponges, and other benthic invertebrates. These consumer-derived nutrients can impact coral growth and physiology, benthic community dynamics, and reef-wide nutrient cycling. Yet, severe over-harvesting, habitat degradation, pollution and climate change may fundamentally change the role of animals in nutrient cycles on reefs. For example, the ongoing defaunation of the oceans likely results in a decrease in nutrient storage and supply by animals as well as a fundamental change in the elemental stoichiometry (ratio of nitrogen and phosphorus) of nutrient supply. These alterations in the delivery of consumer-derived nutrients may fundamentally impact key ecosystem process and cascade down to impacting coral health. However, the ideas around animals as important sources of nutrients on coral reefs is a rapidly developing field with many questions yet to be answered. For example, how can we better quantify the impact of animals on nutrient fluxes in coral reefs? How will climate change affect the impact of consumer-derived nutrients on corals? Will increasing human-derived nutrients alter the impacts of consumer-derived nutrients on reefs? How do changes in benthic communities impact the fate of consumer-derived nutrients? This session will bring together researchers from various fields working on the quantification of nutrient cycling to fill in gaps about how the role of consumers in nutrient fluxes will evolve on coral reefs in the Anthropocene.
David Hughes 1, Andrew Altieri 2, Michael Kuhl3, Maggie Johnson4, Adrienne Correa5
1 University of Technology Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
2 University of Florida (Gainesville, Fl, USA)
3 University of Copenhagen (Copenhagen, Denmark)
4 Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute (Florida, USA)
5 Rice University (Houston, TX, USA)
Ocean deoxygenation is a global phenomenon, with dissolved O2 changing more dramatically than any other environmental variable in recent decades. Research has highlighted the detrimental impact of hypoxia (low dissolved O2) within temperate coastal systems, identifying ecosystem thresholds, or "tipping points" beyond which catastrophic loss of productivity and biodiversity occurs. Yet, the effect of hypoxia on tropical coral reefs has, surprisingly, been almost entirely overlooked relative to thermal stress and ocean acidification. This is despite historical evidence implicating hypoxia as a key factor contributing to mass extinctions of reef organisms, and transient gaps in reef formation over geological timescales. How hypoxia broadly impacts coral reef taxa is largely unknown, including the potential for acclimation or adaptation, and thus predicting how deoxygenation will shape the future form and functioning of coral reefs is currently not possible to currently resolve. In this session we will consider presentations that address how we can begin to define hypoxia stress within coral reef ecosystems and how and when it occurs. For example, how do hypoxia thresholds vary across key coral reef taxa? Is environmental history a key factor determining hypoxia resilience? What physiological and genetic mechanisms are responsible for conferring hypoxia tolerance to coral reef organisms? Do microscale habitats (e.g., the O2 microenvironment) play a key role in mitigating hypoxic stress? Can we disentangle the effects of hypoxia from co-occurring stressors, e.g., temperature and pH? Are urbanised and deep-water tropical reefs particularly vulnerable to deoxygenation events? Can we develop predictive capacity to identify vulnerable taxa or locations most vulnerable to hypoxic stress based on existing empirical data? We encourage submissions that consider all aspects of the hypoxia impacts, from microscale interactions to the wider ecosystem level, aimed at understanding the impacts of low-oxygen stress on coral reef ecosystems and how these can potentially be mitigated by management practices and/or environmental reform.
Ed Hathorne1, Fiorella Prada2, Stefano Goffredo2, Tali Mass 3, Jeana Drake4
1 GEOMAR (Kiel, Germany)
2 University of Bologna (Bologna, Italy)
3 University of Haifa (Haifa, Israel)
4 University of California Los Angeles (Los Angeles, CA, USA)
Corals, algae, bivalves, foraminifera and microbes all calcify and build the reefs that are vital to marine ecosystems yet many of the mechanisms and processes underlying biomineralization remain poorly understood. Calcifying organisms are particularly vulnerable to ocean warming and acidification, potentially reducing the socioeconomic benefits of ecosystems reliant on these taxa. Using novel tools and instrumentation, mechanisms of biomineralization are being elucidated at increasingly finer temporal and spatial scales. This session focuses on present knowledge on the biological and environmental control of biomineral deposition in marine calcifiers, covering recent advances in understanding structural, biogeochemical, molecular, and physiological aspects of biomineralization. We welcome contributions from researchers studying biomineralization using a diverse range of techniques including molecular and genetic studies, laboratory culturing, microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance, pH and ion sensors, skeletal geochemistry and field studies. We are especially interested to hear about newly developed tools as well as well-established protocols used in a novel way. Broadly, we seek to better understand the effects of biotic and abiotic constraints on mineral formation and preservation, and how these translate to persistence of the ability to calcify under potentially detrimental conditions of increased sea surface temperature and nutrient loading and decreased ocean pH. This cross-discipline focus will improve the understanding of all attendees of the fundamental mechanisms of biomineralization and its response to global change.
Nyssa Silbiger, Steve Doo
California State University, Northridge (Northridge, CA, USA)
Current predictions of how coral reef ecosystem processes (e.g. community metabolism) will be altered in projected climate change conditions (e.g. warming, acidification, hypoxia, nutrification etc.) are largely based on laboratory and field experiments that identify sensitives of individual coral reef organisms to various physicochemical parameters. However, recent syntheses and studies suggest that scaling from individual measurements to ecosystem processes on coral reef ecosystems is not linear, and that accurately determining how coral reefs will respond to climate change hinges on a further understanding of scaling processes. The proposed session aims to highlight studies that focus on bridging the gap of understanding how individual measurements scale to ecosystem processes. Contributions to this session are invited on all aspects of furthering understanding of scaling processes, which include but are not limited to studies on modulation of responses to altered environmental conditions (e.g., climate change, eutrophication, etc.) through species interactions, conspecific genotypic variation in responses to climate change stress, experiments that link measurements of individual components to ecosystem measurements. We welcome both empirical and theoretical studies.
Katie Shamberger 1, Thomas DeCarlo2, Kristen Davis3, Andrea Kealoha4, Andrew King5
1 Texas A&M University (College Station, TX, USA)
2 University of Western Australia (Perth, Australia)
3 University of California, Irvine (Irvine, CA, USA)
4 University of Hawaii (Maui, HI, USA)
5 University of Melbourne (Victoria, Australia)
Open-ocean waters flow onto coral reefs, supplying reef ecosystems with food, nutrients, heat, energy, and the chemical components that fuel calcification. The initial conditions of adjacent open-ocean surface waters strongly influence coral reef ecosystem health and functioning. For example, rising temperatures and declining pH in the open ocean are sparking mass coral bleaching events and driving reductions in ecosystem calcification rates. Circulation patterns on and off reefs influence larval dispersal and recruitment, thereby playing a key role in population connectivity and reef recovery following major disturbances. Upwelling of deep, cool waters via internal waves or the interaction of currents with topography can provide intermittent refuge to help mitigate thermal stress. Offshore biological productivity impacts the delivery of inorganic and organic nutrients that serve as critical energy sources for biological processes within coral reef ecosystems. Yet, once on shallow reefs, the open-ocean source waters can be dramatically altered by physical, chemical, and biological processes. Therefore, understanding coral reef ecosystem sensitivity and resilience to climate change requires studies focused on the large-scale oceanography outside the reef, small-scale dynamics within the reef, and interactions between the two. This interdisciplinary session invites observational, laboratory, and modeling-based studies investigating connections between coral-reef and open-ocean processes now and in the future. These processes may include, but are not limited to, ocean acidification and warming; open-ocean productivity and nutrient cycling; and regional and local circulation and physical phenomena. We also encourage submissions aimed at identifying coral reefs whose oceanographic setting provides inherent resilience to climate change, and are therefore top candidates for conservation efforts.
Marji Puotinen1, Nicholas Wolff2, Manuel Gonzalez Rivero3, Joshua Madin4
1 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Crawley, Australia)
2 The Nature Conservancy (Arlington County, VA, USA)
3 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
4 University of Hawaii (Honolulu, HI, USA)
Coral reefs face an existential threat from climate change, most notably from increasingly frequent and severe thermal stress (1). This is exacerbated by damage from other disturbances including tropical cyclone (hurricane) waves (2). While we cannot prevent cyclones now or in future, understanding how their likely frequency and severity varies (and will vary) across the world's reefs is vital to ensure conservation efforts like reef restoration are spatially allocated for maximum benefit (3). Each instance of reef restoration can only be deployed over a limited area due to logistics and cost constraints. Such efforts could be wasted if concentrated on reefs likely to be damaged very frequently by cyclone waves. Despite the importance of this, considerable advances in our knowledge and ability to assess how cyclones damage reefs are not widely known - the most recent review paper on this topic was published in 1994 (4). For example, we've since learned that cyclones can sometimes 'help' reefs by cooling SST during times of escalated thermal stress (5, 6, 7), that the size and longevity of a cyclone can be just as important as its intensity in determining the likelihood of reef damage (8), and that we can predict structural vulnerability of corals based on an index of their shape (9) with important ecological consequences (10). This session would aim to: 1) highlight our current state of knowledge about cyclones and how they interact with other stressors to impact coral reefs, and 2) explore how best to target future cyclone-reef field work and research for maximum benefit to spatial targeting of conservation efforts.
1: Hughes et al 2017 Nature; 2: Cheal et al 2017 Glob Change Biol; 3: Beyers et al 2018 Cons Lett; 4: Harmelin-Vivien 1994 Jrl Coastal Res; 5: Manzello et al 2007 PNAS; 6: Eakin et al 2010 PLoS One; 7: Carrigan & Puotinen 2014 Glob Change Biol; 8: Puotinen et al 2016 Sci Rep 9: Madin & Connelly 2006 Nature; 10 - Madin et al 2014 Ecology Letters.
Aaron MacNeil1, Nicholas Graham2, Michelle Devlin3
1 Dalhousie University (Halifax, Canada)
2 Lancaster University (Lancaster, UK)
3 CEFAS Lowestoft (Lowestoft, UK)
Climate change is emerging as a major determinant of coral reef persistence, yet pervasive threats such as poor water quality and overfishing continue to cause widespread reef decline. While climate change itself is beyond any single jurisdiction, actions on local disturbances have the potential to substantially influence coral reef processes, and thus responses to and recovery from climatic threats. In this symposium we are interested in whether local management of ecosystem characteristics - ecosystem functioning, community structure, and responses through time - can moderate climate-driven reef degradation. We are interested in experimental and observational examples where local impacts do not moderate reef responses to climate change, and examples where mitigation of local impacts has improved reef resistance, recovery, or both.
Potential ideas of interest include:
- Is local driver management redundant in the face of climate change?
- Can changes in water quality mediate coral reef responses to climate change?
- What levels of fishing pressure, or types of management, determine continued ecosystem functioning?
- What are the responses and resilience of interconnected coastal systems including coral reefs, seagrasses, and mangroves?
- Do fishing and water quality interact to determine ecosystem responses to climate change?
- Can key functional groups (effect traits) be enhanced through managing local drivers?
- What novel approaches (co-management, gear exclusions, eDNA, remote sensing, modelling) can we learn from to help manage local pressures on reefs?
We also welcome theoretical or conceptual talks that highlight new or emerging ideas concerning multi-scale, multi-threat futures for coral reef ecosystems.
Riccardo Rodolfo-Metalpa 1, Sylvain Agostini2, Jason M Hall-Spencer3, Marco Milazzo4, Thomas Pichler5
1 IRD (Noumea, New Caledonia)
2 University of Tsukuba (Tsukuba, Japan)
3 University of Plymouth (Plymouth, UK)
4 University of Palermo (Palermo, Italy)
5 University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
In the last ten years, natural analogues of future ocean conditions have become central for the investigation of both species and ecosystem-level responses to climate change. Natural analogues such as CO2 seeps, back reefs, mangrove systems, semi-enclosed lagoons and polluted fringing reefs, augment the in vitro experiments that provide fundamental insight into the mechanisms underpinning reef species responses to environmental change. Their advantage is that they reveal long-term ecological responses in coastal systems. The number and the type of these particular natural laboratories is increasing, now including environments where seawater pCO2 varies simultaneously with other parameters such as temperature, oxygen, nutrients and metal pollutants, all having the potential to interact and affect coral reef survival in the future. However, there are species that surprisingly can survive at natural analogues at conditions unfavourable for corals. Those resilient coral strains likely reveal the mechanisms of acclimatisation and adaptation that reefs of the future will need to keep pace with environmental changes involving multiple stressors. Identify species that are more likely to resist in the future, is particularly important to assist with coral reef conservation. This session will suggest where future scientific effort needs to be focussed to make best use of marine communities living in conditions that mimic future ocean conditions, along with defining best conservation practices to preserve such key biogenic habitats. Studies on reef-forming species from historical and new natural analogues from tropical to high-latitude environments, as well as experiments testing reef builders’ responses to climate change conditions in the wild will greatly improve the discussion. Since natural analogues have limitations when results are used to project the future of reefs, opinion studies are also welcome.
David Suggett1, Tracy Ainsworth 2, Hollie Putnam3
1 University of Technology Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
2 University of New South Wales (Sydney, Australia)
3 University of Rhode Island (Kingston, RI, USA)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 9 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Coral reef organisms are facing unprecedented environmental change, from climate change stressors, such as increasing ocean temperatures and acidity to environmental degradation, such as eutrophication and sedimentation. The physiology of coral reef organisms and their ability and capacity to cope with these changes will ultimately determine the future development of the coral reef ecosystem. What are the physiological responses of reef organisms to biotic changes? Do they adapt to their new environment - at what time scales? - or have they already acclimatized?
This theme focusses on the (functional) physiology of reef organism in general, from molecular to cellular to organism processes, including but not limited to physiological plasticity, phenotype-genotype interactions and behavioural changes. This includes not only the host organisms, but also the microbiome of the respective holobionts. We aim to advance our knowledge of the mechanisms underlying the capacity of coral reef organisms/holobionts to survive and thrive in a coral reef ecosystem, at present state and under rapidly changing ocean conditions.
Andrea Grottoli 1, Robert Toonen2, Robert van Woesik3, James Price1, Kerri Dobson1
1 The Ohio State University (Columbus, OH, USA)
2 Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology (Lillipuna, HI, USA)
3 Florida Institute of Technology (Melbourne, Fl, USA)
Coral bleaching is responsible for massive coral loss globally. As climate change continues, the frequency and intensity of coral bleaching will increase. Yet some corals survive thermal stress events, and either do not bleach or bleach and recover. In this session we will explore the physiological, biogeochemical, and microbial processes that underlie the vulnerability and tolerance of corals to thermal stress and bleaching. We are particularly interested in the response of corals to multiple stressors, in determining the reaction norms of different coral phenotypes and genotypes across a range of environmental stressors, and in the interrelationships between genotype, phenotype, and environmental factors in determining response characteristics.
Sarah Davies 1, Carly Kenkel2, Ross Cunning 3, Jeremie Vidal-Dupiol 4
1 Boston University (Boston, Ma, USA)
2 University of Southern California (Los Angeles, CA, USA)
3 John G. Shedd Aquarium (Chicago, IL, USA)
4 Université de Montpellier (Montpellier, France)
Plasticity is the ability of an individual to produce a range of phenotypes in response to environmental variation. Understanding the drivers and consequences of phenotypic variation is critical for predicting organismal responses to environmental change. Many marine organisms encounter environments favoring different phenotypic optima, however the relationship between the direction and magnitude of plasticity and fitness (survival and/or reproduction) remains unknown. While prior experience can significantly alter subsequent responses to stress, the importance of time-lags between cue and response, as well as the capacity for reversibility remain unexplored. The mechanisms giving rise to plasticity are also unresolved, but may include genetic and non-genetic mechanisms that can function at different levels of the holobiont (an organism and its associated microbiota). Given that environments are rapidly changing, phenotypic plasticity that may have previously been essential to efficiently respond to certain environments might become adaptive. Finally, for certain taxa, such as corals, understanding how plasticity shapes responses to novel reef environments will be critical to the success of applied restoration activities. This session is focused on understanding the role(s) that plasticity might play in acclimatization or adaptation of reef organisms to environmental change.
Manuel Aranda Lastra1, Hollie Putnam2, Mikhail Matz3
1 KAUST (Thuwal, Saudi Arabia)
2 The University of Rhode Island (Kingston, RI, USA)
3 The University of Texas at Austin (Austin, TX, USA)
The alarming decline of coral reef health worldwide has raised concerns that the rate of global change might outpace the capacity of reef organisms to evolve in response to these threats. In addition to genetic adaptation, which is based on natural selection operating on populations, all organisms are capable of acclimating to environmental change to some extent using environment-driven phenotypic modifications, or “plasticity”, happening at the individual level. These “epigenetic” mechanisms include various molecular processes such as DNA methylation, histone modifications and small non-coding RNAs. These mechanisms can dynamically alter gene expression to better suit different environmental conditions and, at least in theory, could have lasting effects extending beyond the lifetime of a single individual and contribute to the population-level adaptive response in the long term. The study of epigenetic mechanisms as means for reef organisms to adapt to a changing environment is becoming increasingly important for our understanding of coral reef resilience in the context of global climate change. This session will serve as a platform for scientists working on epigenetics in reef organisms to present and discuss their findings, and to introduce this emerging field of study to a broader audience.
Timothy Ravasi1, Iliana Baums2, Jose M. Eirin-Lopez3, Gergely Torda4
1 KAUST (Thuwal, Saudi Arabia)
2 Pennsylvania State University (State College, PA, USA)
3 Florida International University (Miami, Fl, USA)
4 ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies (Townsville, Australia)
Anthropogenic activities alter the climate and ecosystems globally, making it increasingly challenging for organisms to keep pace with the associated rapid ecological changes in their environment. Coral reefs are particularly affected due to the sensitivity of the sessile or sedentary organisms that form the backbone of these ecosystems. The worldwide decline of coral reef ecosystems made it imperative to better understand the mechanisms underpinning evolutionary processes and how they influence and are influenced by demographic processes, population connectivity, interspecific interactions, and the interaction of species with their abiotic environment. These ecological processes are important in directing and constraining evolutionary processes, and in turn evolutionary change greatly affects (meta)population trajectories. This session aims to bridge the gap between the fields of coral reef ecology and evolution, bringing together ecologists, evolutionary biologists, physiologists, molecular biologists, microbiologists and modelers to brainstorm about how ecological changes associated with climate change will influence the adaptive capacity of (meta)populations of coral reef organisms. In addition, special emphasis will be put on discussing the various avenues for adaptation and acclimatization of coral reef organisms, including modifications in the genome, epigenome and microbiome. This session aims to not only contribute novel data but also robust experimental designs, innovative theories and synthesis talks to drive research addressing acclimatization, adaptation and metapopulation evolution. We are confident this session will be of interest for a wide audience among participants of the ICRS 2020, specifically (but not limited to) those interested in coral reef ecology and evolution, reef-omics, coral conservation, coral epigenome, and microbiome.
Nikki Traylor-Knowles 1, Caroline Palmer2, Laura Mydlarz3
1 University of Miami, RSMAS (Miami, Fl, USA)
2 University of Plymouth (Plymouth, UK)
3 University of Texas at Arlington (Arlington, TX, USA)
Coral immunology is a relatively young yet expanding, interdisciplinary research field that may hold the key to understanding and promoting the health and survival of coral reefs. Coral immunity maintains health, determines holobiont interactions and underlies susceptibility, tolerance and resilience to all perturbations - from pathogens to climate-change induced environmental shifts. Coral immunity drives patterns at ecological scales, is an essential component of coral biology and is therefore vital for effectively tackling the coral reef crisis. Coral immunology encompasses a broad range of scientific disciplines ensuring this session will appeal to many. We welcome studies across biological scales, on topics such as evolution, biochemistry, genomics, cell biology, molecular biology and ecology. This unique session will highlight the relevance and impact of coral immunology from gene to reef, and welcome immunological topics including: allorecognition, mechanisms and physiology, effectors and responses, ecological immunity, response to and effects of climate change, symbiosis and holobiome interactions, pathogen interactions and applications to coral reef conservation and restoration.
Ulisse Cardini 1, Adriana Vergés2
1 Stazione Zoologica Anton Dohrn (Napoli, Italy)
2 University of New South Wales (Kensington, Australia)
Oceans are getting warmer, and subtropical and temperate seas worldwide increasingly experience the intrusion of tropical species, a process called 'tropicalization'. Tropicalization has already led to profound transformations in some ecological communities, including detrimental effects on temperate algal and gorgonian forests, as well as poleward shifts in tropical seagrasses that compete with native counterparts. Ultimately, a range of important ecosystem services may be affected. Novel approaches to address this problem are needed. For example, since it is now clear that marine organisms are not self-complete but rather form with their associated micro-organisms entities called holobionts, it is paramount to investigate the role played by microbial partners in the ability of species to either adapt to warmer conditions or shift their distribution to stay within a preferred thermal range. The Mediterranean Sea, the widest marine warm-temperate region in the world, represents a large scale natural experiment for observation of the role of holobionts in the tropicalization of marine ecosystems. Other hotspots, such as Japan, Australia and Brazil, are equally relevant and testify to the global scale of the phenomenon. This multidisciplinary session will serve as a platform to report on the biology and ecology of high latitude reefs and tropical-temperate transition zones, where the ecological consequences derived from the intrusion of tropical species are likely to manifest first, and on the role that microbes may play in adaptation to non-native environments. More generally, the session will focus on the ecological impacts of tropical organisms in subtropical and temperate systems and the associated shifts in species interactions and ecosystem functioning.
Celia Schunter1, Rohan Brooker2, Sally Keith 3
1 The University of Hong Kong (Hong Kong, HKSAR)
2 Deakin University (Victoria, Australia)
3 Lancaster University (Lancaster, UK)
Human impacts on marine ecosystems are increasingly apparent and severe, with climate change, coastal development, and rapid exploitation occurring at the expense of habitat quality and biodiversity. For coral reef organisms, behavioural responses to environmental change can influence vulnerability; while species or individuals that can modify their behaviour to exploit new conditions may persist those that are inflexible may decline. Behavioural adjustments to rapid change can therefore have broader ecosystem-level effects, mediating population structure and evolution through shifts to key processes such as mate choice, dispersal, and migration. However, while some alterations can be beneficial, others are maladaptive, or have varying effects over the short and long-term. Given the complex relationship between behaviour and environmental change, it is critical that we determine the environmental and biological factors that influence behaviour under both current and future conditions. This includes examining the neurological and molecular mechanisms underlying behaviour and their adaptive potential, the impact of long-term environmental change on behaviourally mediated processes and ecosystem function, and how behaviour can be harnessed to increase ecosystem resilience. To this end, this multidisciplinary symposium will draw together expertise from a range of fields to examine the links between behaviour and environmental change. It will contribute to a greater, cross-disciplinary, understanding of how behavioural adjustments occur with changing environmental conditions, how these changes affect the ecology within coral reef ecosystems, and increase our capacity to develop informed conservation and management responses.
Jasper de Goeij1, Verena Schoepf2
1 University of Amsterdam (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
2 University of Western Australia (Perth, Australia)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 10 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Over the last decades, coral reefs have been threatened and impacted globally by natural and anthropogenic stressors at an increasing and unprecedented scale. For example, overfishing, water pollution, and extreme climatic events have led to significant changes in the development of coral reef communities resulting in reefs in which the biomass is now dominated by benthic organisms other than scleractinian corals. This theme is aiming for contributions that investigate both the resilience of reef communities to environmental changes as well as shifts in reef communities occurring at various stages of ecosystem development. We invite (1) studies identifying and assessing resilience mechanisms, including changes in the functional biodiversity within certain taxonomic classes, that prevent coral reef ecosystems from community shifts, (2) studies describing (functional) biodiversity changes in reef communities, possibly leading to novel ecosystems where biomass and structure is not provided by scleractinian corals, and (3) studies identifying and assessing biotic and abiotic drivers of these community shifts.
Brigitte Sommer 1, David Booth2, Yohei Nakamura3, Maria Beger4
1 The University of Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
2 University of Technology Sydney (Sydney, Australia)
3 Kochi University (Nankoku, Kochi, Japan)
4 University of Leeds (Leeds, UK)
Climate change is markedly transforming marine ecosystems as differential species responses to warming, species migrations and species abundance changes lead to altered dominance patterns, novel species configurations and interactions. These changes are already occurring in many systems, including tropical coral reefs post bleaching and along biogeographic transition zones, where tropical and temperate species overlap at their range limits. Nevertheless, the dynamics and mechanisms driving these changes and how they affect ecosystem function are poorly understood. Multi-taxon studies are therefore critically needed to understand the links between community composition, species interactions and environmental conditions and to predict future trajectories for marine ecosystems. We invite presentations that focus on multi-taxon research (e.g. corals, algae, fish) in tropical-to-temperate systems, from local field experiments to global analysis and ecosystems models. We particularly encourage presentations from high-latitude systems, where species range shifts (e.g. of corals and tropical fishes) and altered species interactions (e.g. altered herbivory patterns) and functions are already transforming ecosystems.
Christine Ferrier-Pagès 1, Sergio Rossi2, Yehuda Benayahu3
1 Centre Scientifique de Monaco (Monaco)
2 University of Salento (Lecce, Italy)
3 Tel Aviv University (Tel Aviv, Israel)
Coral reefs worldwide have suffered significant declines in coral cover and species diversity, due to the combined effects of global change, pollution and diseases, among others. In many areas like the Caribbean or the Great Barrier, the role of stony corals as architects of the ecosystem is substituted by other three-dimensional alive structures. For example, these changes are often associated with shifts from hard coral-dominated communities to macroalgae, sponges or octocoral-dominated communities. During the last decades, a huge effort has been made to understand scleractinian coral distribution or demography, reproduction or growth, physiology or symbiotic patterns, but relatively little is known on the autoecology and the ecosystem role of the other benthic groups and on their response to environmental perturbations. This clearly limits our capacity to forecast and understand future changes in the seascape of tropical systems. Our session will focus on the structure and function of octocoral, sponge and macroalgal communities, in coral reef ecosystems and how they are affected by the ongoing environmental changes. We invite contributions that examine the ecology, life history, physiology, trophic ecology and symbiotic relationships of these benthic groups and the mechanisms underlying their resilience under environmental and anthropogenic stress. We will be encouraging submissions across all geographic regions, where octocorals, sponges and macroalgae play an increasing role in the ecosystem. We will also encourage young participants to contribute this session.
Janie Wulff 1, Christine Schönberg2
1 Florida State University (Tallahassee, FL, USA)
2 University of Western Australia (Crawley, Australia)
Controversy over sponge functional roles and how sponge populations are controlled on coral reefs has become polarized and, given the many key roles played by sponges, it seems important to see how we can reconcile contrasting views of sponge influences and dynamics. Contrasting reports that: a) sponges are overwhelming corals and reefs vs. suffering mass mortalities; b) sponges are controlled by spongivores vs. by picoplankton and nutrient availability; and c) sponge effects on corals are damaging vs. enhancing, result in opposing conclusions that impede clear predictions of future states. Potentially profound reciprocal influences of sponges and the water column on each other, as well as of sponges and corals on each other, impel increased attention to focused studies of sponge ecology. Sponges must also be added to monitoring, conservation, restoration, and management plans, but the most useful and efficient ways to do this require thoughtful conversation, as standard coral reef techniques must be modified to take into account how sponges differ from corals, i.e., an order of magnitude greater species diversity, living tissue throughout their 3-dimensional bodies, disintegrating upon death rather than leaving behind a skeleton, capable of inhabiting cryptic spaces where evaluation is difficult, and playing a greater variety of ecosystem functional roles. We hope to facilitate movement from polarized debate to discussion of circumstances under which contrasting results are obtained. Are contrasting reports due to focus on different species? generalization from too few or unusual species? different metrics and techniques used? field sites varying in key aspects? temporal and spatial scales dissimilar? We will provide a forum for presentation and discussion of new data to address the balance between bottom-up vs. top-down controls on sponges, positive vs. negative functional roles of sponges, and increasing vs. decreasing populations of sponges.
Alastair Harborne 1, Mary Donovan 2, David Kochan1, Matthew Mitchell3, Alice Rogers4
1 Florida International University (Miami, Fl, USA)
2 University of California, Santa Barbara (Santa Barbara, Ca, USA)
3 NYU Abu Dhabi (Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates)
4 Victoria University (Wellington, New Zealand)
The multiple threats degrading coral reefs are widely recognized as reducing coral cover, and consequently reef complexity and structure. Complexity is critical for maintaining diverse and abundant fish assemblages because of the need of many species to use reef structure for nesting, foraging, spawning, refuge from predators, and to maintain themselves in high-flow environments. Consequently, reef structure underpins the key ecosystem service of protein provision, and loss of complexity is having profound impacts on fish and fisheries. However, despite the well-established links between fish and structure, many questions remain including how structure mediates reef food webs (e.g. consumptive and non-consumptive predator-prey interactions and trophic structure), affects inter- and intra-specific competition, changes fish behavior and physiology, and impacts fish catches and profits. For example, there are few data on the multiple impacts of reduced reef complexity on prey species (e.g. earlier detection of predators) and predators (e.g. altered hunting efficiency), and the implications for their demographics and ultimately catchable biomass. Answering such questions has recently benefited from new ways to explore and quantify reef structure at multiple scales, particularly through three-dimensional digital reef reconstructions that can now be undertaken with simple cameras and off-the-shelf software. This session aims to bring together an interdisciplinary series of talks and posters that address any aspect of the relationship between reef structure and fish and fisheries. We welcome submissions on any topic related to fish and reef complexity, including studies that address characterizing reef complexity, consider the effects on fish ecology, demography, behavior, or physiology, examine the impacts of reduced reef structure on fisheries and human food security, and suggest conservation initiatives including reef restoration and artificial reefs to increase structure.
Fleur Van Duyl 1, Erik Meesters2, Lisa Becking3, Petra Visser4
1 NIOZ (Den Burg, Texel, The Netherlands)
2 Wageningen University and Research (Den Helder, The Netherlands)
3 Wageningen University and Research (Wageningen, The Netherlands)
4 University of Amsterdam (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
Benthic cyanobacterial mats increase worldwide on coral reefs. Benthic filamentous cyanobacteria are common on reefs, but the cover and density of mats has increased the last two decades with up to 30% on many present day reefs. Their presence in the past was more concealed e.g. as subgroup in algal-dominated turfs on hard bottom substrates. Nowadays you can find dense filamentous mats growing on sand, bare hard substratum, macroalgae as well as next to and on live corals. Mats appear to be dominated by common cyanobacterial species such as Lyngbya majuscule, Oscillatoria sp. Moreover, mats can be toxic and their palatability is overall low. Putative drivers of mat development are pollution (eutrophication by sewage, freshwater flooding, iron input, degrading reefs) and temperature. Calm hydrodynamic conditions might be required for the establishment of mats. The local wax and wane of mats tends to be highly variable in space and time, which casts doubt on the role of different drivers. Interesting is the not well-understood sudden disappearance of mats. Is this due to e.g. grazing by herbivores, microbial degradation, burial or dislodgement and transport? Mats are known for their fixation of nitrogen and release of bioavailable nitrogen and dissolved organic matter (OM) during day and night. Mats appear to be the strongest OM releasers of all benthic primary producers per unit surface area of reef. As a consequence of the consortium metabolism, mats can become anoxic during the night. Pelagic microbes stimulated by the OM release may further contribute to hypoxic conditions in the benthic boundary layer. Such hypoxic conditions may persevere in stagnant water under, within and above dense mats during day and night which may be harmful or deleterious to corals in the mat-coral interaction zone and interaction with other benthic reef organisms (macroalgae, sponges, crustose coralline algae). Little is known whether toxins excreted by the mats may also deter settlement of larvae and harm neighbouring benthic reef organisms. We welcome contributions on distribution, wax and wane of mats, chemical fluxes in and out of mats, toxicity, grazing and molecular ecology including metagenomics of mats and interactions between mats and other benthic organisms.
Peter J. Schupp1, Jasper de Goeij2, Verena Schoepf 3
1 University of Oldenburg (Oldenburg, Germany)
2 University of Amsterdam (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
3 University of Western Australia (Perth, Australia)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 11 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
With a growing recognition of the imperiled status of many of the world’s coral reefs, their management and conservation has received increasing attention in recent decades. New approaches are underpinned by advances in ecological theory, such as resilience-based management, or draw on technological innovations and novel tools, assisting for example in marine spatial planning and the real-time inclusion of data on different scales in management decisions. Insights from traditional forms of management are used to inform the design of management plans in a range of places, and increasingly consideration is given to participatory approaches, exchange of information and learning, while advances in governance theory and other fields of the humanities are improving the theoretical underpinning of management. These are just a few examples of the many ways management and conservation are gearing up to meet the challenges facing coral reefs in the 21st century. Theme 12 welcomes presentations that explore different examples and approaches of coral reef conservation and management and their underpinnings.
Elizabeth Shaver 1, Elizabeth Mcleod1, Kenneth Anthony2, Jennifer Koss3
1 The Nature Conservancy (Arlington, VA, USA)
2 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
3 NOAA Coral Reef Conservation Program (Silver Spring, MD, USA)
Decades of human impacts and global climate change have devastated the world's coral reefs, with 2017 marking the end of the world's longest, most widespread, and possibly most damaging coral bleaching event in history. To counter the global decline of coral reefs, scientists have called for a move beyond conventional management to a focus on supporting the resilience of coral reefs, dependent people, and economies. Resilience - defined as the capacity of a system to withstand stressors, maintain its structure and function in the face of disturbance, and adapt to future challenges - has been proposed as a guiding framework for coral reef management in an era characterized by rapid global change. However, continued decline of both isolated and intensively managed reefs raises the question of how to best incorporate resilience into management and whether managing for resilience is a viable strategy to protect reefs in the face of climate change. In this session, presentations will provide key insights into the question: what is the evidence base for resilience-based management and where is this field going in the future? This session welcomes oral and poster presentations on cutting-edge reef resilience science, including current and future applications, and identification of new ways to support resilience. Resilience approaches may include, but are not limited to, conventional methods (e.g., herbivore protection, reduction of local threats), restoration interventions (e.g., assisted evolution or colonization, gene editing, supportive breeding), or innovative approaches (e.g., geo-engineering).
Melanie McField1, Lisa Carne2, Anastasia Banaszak3, Nadia Bood4
1 Healthy Reefs Initiative, Smithsonian Institution (Florida, USA)
2 Fragments of Hope (Belize)
3 National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) (MC, Mexico)
4 World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) (Belize)
Coral reefs around the world are facing unprecedented levels of stress due to global pressures like climate change and ocean acidification, as well as regional and local stress factors like pollution and overfishing. Significant conservation and management efforts are underway but are struggling match the scale and speed of the widespread potential ecosystem collapse facing reefs. Although there has been much progress in the science of conservation and restoration of coral reefs and, including key ecosystem functions and services, most activities around the globe have not reached ecosystem-scale. There are many reasons for this including lack of financing, human capacity, political will or the required legal framework. This session will therefore invite stakeholders from areas and projects that are on their way towards scaling success or have achieved large-scale successes in coral reef preservation to analyze the enabling conditions that have made the range of their efforts possible as well as the limiting factors or restrictions they had to overcome. The session will follow the main thematic lines of:
- Networking and collaborations, including different actors and across sectors
- Strengthening political will and influencing a beneficial legal environment
- Good governance for reef restoration and conservation
- Securing long-term, sustainable financing for coral reef conservation and restoration
Thus, it will identify best as well as worst practice examples and serve as a platform to foster mutual learning and exchange. The identification of major obstacles to overcome and the needs in communicating coral conservation needs to a broad range of stakeholders will complement the discussions.
Anna Maria Addamo1,2, Mariagrazia Graziano1, Francesca Santoro3, Thamasak Yeemin4, Vo Si Tuan5
1 European Commission, JRC (Ispra, Italy),
2 National Museum of Natural Sciences (Madrid, Spain)
3 IOC, UNESCO (Venice, Italy)
4 Marine Science Association of Thailand (Bangkok, Thailand)
5 Institute of Oceanography Vietnam (Nha Trang, Vietnam)
Ocean Literacy has been defined as the understanding of the ocean’s influence on humankind, as well as our own influence on the ocean itself. The main objective is to educate people, offering information and tools that would allow all to make sensible decisions when it comes to the ocean and its resources. The Marine Natural Capital is the ocean’s stock of natural assets, which include living organisms and their habitats, and whence human survival and well-being derive in a wide range of ecosystem services. While the Blue Economy identifies the economic activities that indirectly and directly use resources from the ocean and the coastal areas, the Sustainable Blue Economy is the joint economy activity based on healthy, resilient and productive marine environments, which include coral reefs. Coastal and island communities highly depend on the ecosystem services provided by coral reefs. Living without coral reefs, whether they are shallow, deep, tropical or cold water will be challenging and prove so. Coral reefs provide resources for fisheries, coastal protection, recreation and tourism, thereby the basis for human’ livelihoods and national economies. Climate change, ocean acidification, unsustainable use, ceaseless rise demand for marine resources, have led to the classification of coral reefs as Vulnerable or severely Threatened Ecosystems. A call for Blue Growth has been globally raised to support sustainable approaches with a hope of reconciling economic development and the conservation of marine ecosystem services. Quantifying coral reef ecosystem services and how society and blue businesses (incl. emerging sectors) can truly benefit from sustainable practices are the core of the session on Coral Reefs and Sustainable Blue Economy. Ocean communication, ecological goods and services of coral reef ecosystems; community-based management of ecosystem services; economic evaluation of benefits derived from coral reefs; opportunities and risks to business associated to the reef ecosystem and its degradation; challenges and solutions for a sustainable use of coral reefs in the blue economy era. These are some but definitely not all the questions that need to be addressed, in order to assess the various facets of critical value of coral reefs for the sustainable blue economic development of human society.
Kenneth Anthony 1, Paul Hardisty1, Elizabeth Shaver 2
1 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
2 The Nature Conservancy (Arlington, VA, USA)
Decision problems on coral reefs are becoming increasingly wicked. New interventions and management strategies are developing, but reefs are in decline and the window of opportunity to act is closing with climate change. More options, but limited time and a complex but degrading system means more uncertainty. Which choice is risky, safe, beneficial, and for whom? How can reef managers, policy makers and conservation practitioners best tackle this growing decision challenge? This session will bring the best of multidisciplinary, structured decision-making to bear on this problem. Our unifying question will be: what guiding principles should we give decision-makers at different levels? We will address this question for reefs a social-ecological systems with multiple, often conflicting, objectives. We invite contributions from high-level government officials to on-reef conservation practitioner, biologists to economists, behavioural psychologists to systems modellers. Our session will underpin the symposium's theme "Tackling the Challenging Future of Coral Reefs" by bringing clarity and transparency to decision problems and solutions for coral reefs and dependent people. We will work with our speakers to ensure we deliver an integrated and coherent session with clear messages that a diverse audience can benefit from. The session will be interactive, entertaining and engaging. We start with a scene-setting talk with subsequent talks playing directly into the theme laid out by the scene-setter. We hope to end the day with a Public Forum. Here we will showcase a few illustrative, timely decision problems that call for urgent solutions. Contributors, invited experts and the audience will tackle these with the sessions chairs or an invited facilitator, and using the principles developed during the day's session. Lastly, we will invite the contributors to join us in writing a policy-relevant publication based on what we develop during the session.
Sebastian Ferse 1, Annette Breckwoldt1, Valerie Cummins2
1 Leibniz Centre for Tropical Marine Research (ZMT) (Bremen, Germany)
2 University College Cork (Cork, Ireland)
Designing appropriate management approaches that ensure a protection and sustainable use of coral reef ecosystems in light of projected environmental and societal changes requires participatory and transdisciplinary approaches in research and development of management plans. In this session, we want to bring together a range of researchers and practitioners from a broad range of backgrounds to exchange experiences with such approaches and distil lessons learned by comparison across different cases. Potential topics include, but are not limited to:
- participatory research with the aim of gathering actionable results
- the use of alternative scenarios for the co-design of management plans
- integration of natural and social science data in models to develop a basis for policy decisions
- integration of local and traditional forms of knowledge with academic scientific information
- characteristics of suitable fora for interaction and exchange of views
- analyses of participatory processes in policy design
- trade-offs between ecological, socio-economic and cultural targets
- incorporating uncertainty about future social-ecological system configuration in decision-making
Target disciplines range from sociology, humanities, political sciences, social-ecological modelling to legal studies and economics. A final synthesis discussion is envisioned to lead to a review paper (suggested topics: characteristics of suitable formats for co-design of management, use of scenarios for planning, legal enabling conditions and barriers to co-design of management).
Tauna Rankin 1, Supin Wongbusarakum2, Juan J. Cruz-Motta3, Nygiel B. Armada4, Bill Arnold 5
1 NOAA (Silver Spring, MD, USA)
2 University of Hawaii (Honolulu, HI, USA)
3 University of Puerto Rico (Mayaguez, Puerto Rico)
4 USAID Fish Right Program (Philippines)
5 NOAA Fisheries (St. Petersburg, FL, USA)
Coral reef fisheries present a multitude of challenges to conventional fisheries management that focuses on a sectoral perspective and target stocks. These challenges include the high diversity of species, variety of fishing gears and methods, a wide range of coastal resource uses, and degraded states of coastal habitats and species. These factors, combined with limited management resources, lead to notoriously sparse information on the biology and status of stocks and lack of adequate understanding of socio-cultural and economic dependence on these stocks and the supporting coral reef ecosystems. Thus, effective management and conservation requires a more holistic and inclusive approach that addresses the complex and dynamic features of the ecosystems that provide goods and services beyond those of benefit to coral reef fisheries. The concept of ecosystem-based fisheries management (EBFM) has been around for several decades and key strengths include its capacity for multivariable consideration of physical, biological, economic and social interactions in fisheries management areas, through a place-based approach that engages stakeholders. This is an underutilized opportunity that would facilitate an examination of trade-offs as a means to optimize benefits among a diverse set of societal goals and bolster ecosystem resilience. An effective EBFM framework can help managers better plan for changes to coral reef condition and functions, as well as human and ecological communities. Despite the sound principles and benefits of EBFM, its implementation has been limited. This session will share successful approaches and insightful lessons from different countries/regions on how EBFM has been applied, thereby providing guidance as to what it takes to make the successful shift from conventional fisheries management to ecosystem-based management for coral reef-dependent fisheries, even in data-poor areas.
Katja Mintenbeck, Elvira Poloczanska, Maike Nicolai
IPCC Working Group II TSU c/o AWI Bremerhaven (Bremen, Germany)
"Tackling the Challenging Future of Coral Reefs" in the light of global climate change requires more than just stocktaking of accumulated knowledge - it requires changes in public awareness and behaviour, and global policy. Scientific knowledge, distilled into comprehensive and understandable assessments, raises broad attention and informs policy decisions. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) supports these processes by connecting science and policy. In the current Sixth Assessment Cycle (AR6), the IPCC products include three Special Reports agreed in response to proposals by its member governments. These Special Reports address highly policy-relevant issues: (i) Global Warming of 1.5°C, the Special Report that sheds more light on limits of warming defined in the Paris Agreement (launched in October 2018), (ii) Climate Change and Land (due August 2019), and (iii) Ocean and Cryosphere in a Changing Climate (due September 2019). The three IPCC Working Groups (WGI, WGII, WGIII) are also preparing their contributions to the main Sixth Assessment Report (due 2021). The Working Group II contribution focusses on Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. The impacts and risks of climate change to ecosystems and human systems are assessed in the IPCC Reports including coral reefs and human communities that depend on them under scenarios of warming and ocean acidification. The rate and magnitude of climate change as well as societal and policy choices for adaptation and mitigation actions will determine future challenges for these important systems. This session will start with an overview of the work of the IPCC at the science-policy interface by Hans-Otto Pörtner, IPCC WGII Co-Chair. We invite authors of IPCC Reports to present key findings from the Reports relevant to the overarching theme of the Conference. A large portion of the session is dedicated to open discussion, with all presenters forming a panel to take questions from the audience. The overall aim of this session is to inform researchers on the work of the IPCC and encourage them to add their voices to the ongoing IPCC assessment through production of literature, reviewing drafts and nominating for future IPCC meetings and reports.
Marie-Lise Schläppy 1, Hugh Posssingham2, Line Bay 3, Verena Schoepf4
1 UWA/AIMS (Crawley, Australia)
2 The Nature Conservancy (Arlington, VA, USA)
3 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Townsville, Australia)
4 The University of Western Australia (Perth, Australia)
Coral reefs are being impacted by a number of anthropogenic impacts and, in a context of limited resources to fund conservation and restoration projects, difficult decisions must be made about where and when to act. Triage methods such as those used in the medical field, can be used to prioritize conservation and restoration actions to target coral reefs that need it the most or where the action will be most beneficial. In the field of terrestrial ecology, the legitimacy of such methods is being questioned as those in opposition of these methods argue that ecosystems that are not selected for conservation or restoration are effectively abandoned. The proponents of such methods point that the inaction that stems from not making a decision and delaying action often amounts to making a decision that can be deleterious to the ecosystem in need of conservation. In this session, we welcome presentations that address the issue of prioritization of conservation and restoration projects on coral reefs. We invite presentations of case-studies on how prioritization was achieved, theoretical frameworks that may help in decision-making (e.g. novel ecosystem framework, Investment Framework for Environmental Resources (INFFER)) and on which dimensions may be used (e.g. ecosystem services, values linking to human well-being) to underpin those decisions.
Jason Philibotte 1, Petra MacGowan 2, Dana Wusinich-Mendez 1, Michael Lameier3, Jennifer Koss 1
1 NOAA Coral Reef Conservation Program (Silver Spring, MD, USA)
2 The Nature Conservancy (Arlington, VA, USA)
3 NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service (Silver Spring, MD, USA)
Creating 'communities of practice' for marine managed and protected areas have become a valuable and cost-efficient tool to support coral reef conservation efforts. This relatively new approach to coral reef conservation aims to increase management effectiveness by providing opportunities for local managers and practitioners to share information, expertise, and experience with other network members and access experts to develop and strengthen local management capacity. These social learning networks (Learning Networks) provide institutional capacity and a foundation to maintain standards, raise funds, and manage knowledge over the long-term. While Learning Networks can be classified in two major categories, 1) geographic focus, (i.e. PIMPAC - The Pacific Island Managed and Protected Area Community) and 2) topical focus (i.e. Reef Resilience Network), the primary goal of both is to connect resource managers, provide access to new science and tools, build local capacity, increase management effectiveness, and share knowledge and lessons learned. During the session, representatives from learning networks will present on the various value propositions, governance structures, knowledge exchange activities, limitations, evaluation approaches, and common priorities of learning networks to help answer the question - Do learning networks lead to better local marine management and enhanced coral reef conservation efforts?
Sangeeta Mangubhai1, Danika Kleiber2,3, Sarah Lawless2, Elizabeth Matthews4
1 Wildlife Conservation Society (Suva, Fiji)
2 JCU, ARC Centre of Excellence (Townsville, Australia)
3 WorldFish (Penang, Malaysia)
4 Wildlife Conservation Society (New York, NY, USA)
Small-scale coral reef fisheries provide an important source of food and livelihoods for millions of people in coastal communities. However, coral reefs and the fisheries they support are in rapid decline and require innovative and strategic interventions to ensure their recovery. Increasingly human rights based approaches are used to frame and implement small-scale fisheries management1. Gender is recognized as an integral component of a human rights approach. Whilst there is growing engagement with gender integrated approaches in coral reef fisheries science and management (i.e., accounting for the different contributions of women and men), the full potential has yet to be realized. There has not been the equivalent effort to integrate gender into other types of management tools or approaches, such as marine protected areas or land-sea planning. This session hopes to attract speakers for a diversity of geographies and will explore the impact of integrating gender in the science and management of coral reefs, particularly in the context of food security, livelihoods and research. The session will aim to explore the following questions:
- How does taking a gender approach improve outcomes for fisheries management?
- How does gender integration improve coral reef science and in particular our understanding of the links between human social systems and coral reefs?
- How do social, economic, and cultural contexts affect gender integration into coral reef management?
- How does the inclusion of gender in coral reef science and management contribute to universal commitments to human rights, gender equality and other human development goals we aspire to as a global community?
Stacy Jupiter 1, Kim Falinski2, Amelia Wenger3, Jade Delevaux4
1 Wildlife Conservation Society, Melanesia Program (Suva, Fiji)
2 The Nature Conservancy (Arlington, VA, USA)
3 The University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
4 University of Hawaii (Manoa, HI, USA)
Managing downstream impacts from land-based activities is regarded as an important component of maintaining or restoring coral reef system resilience due to the direct and indirect negative impacts of sediments, nutrients and chemicals on reef organisms. However, it is often difficult to identify where to optimally target land-based management given the complex biophysical and chemical processes that affect the magnitude and geographic fate of land-based pollutants. This session will explore emerging new tools that build the evidence base that catchment management can be effective for improving water quality and reef condition. We will also highlight new innovations in integrated land-sea modelling that enable geographic prioritization of where to target and scale management actions. Presented case studies will showcase empirical and modelled outcomes of catchment management in coral reef social-ecological systems for both reefs (e.g., impacts to benthic cover and reef fish communities) and people (e.g., impacts to livelihoods, health and well-being). We will also discuss the imperative for transdisciplinary collaboration to better understand pathways of impact and link scientific evidence to management practice.
Janina Seemann1, Axel Krumsiek 2, Kerstin Pliegner 3, Claudia Mayer4
1 Zukunft - Umwelt - Gesellschaft gGmbH (Berlin, Germany)
2 World Wide Fund for Nature (Hamburg, Germany)
3 The Nature Conservancy (Berlin, Germany)
4 German Corporation for Int. Cooperation GmbH (Bonn, Germany)
The rate of coral loss around the world is increasing and coral reefs are faced with an increasing amount of negative impacts. Scientists, conservation practitioners and policy-makers alike are struggling to keep pace and conserve coral reefs. Often coral reef conservation and scientific endeavors are insufficiently linked to achieve the scale and impact that is needed. In order to make measurable impacts, the urgency to strengthen synergies and interlinkages between science and policy will be critical. Thus, the aim of this session is to provide a global overview of the activities and success stories in coral reef management from all around the world by providing the practitioners themselves with the voice to share their case studies. Together with participants from the scientific realm, civil society and developing agencies key success factors will be analyzed and discussed what remaining challenges are. This session will identify at which level the exchange between science and reef conservation has been successful in the past (best practice examples) and which are the obstacles and challenges to overcome for the future. Furthermore, it will point out where lacks in communication or data exchange have led to setbacks (worst practice exchange) and thereby present a panorama of joint approaches that aimed at or were able to successfully conserve, protect and restore coral reefs and their ecosystem services. The session will present infrastructures, platforms and tools that already exist or would be needed to facilitate and optimize the exchange and cooperation between science and conservation. It will provide a unique opportunity for a dialogue between the scientific community and conservation practitioners, allowing understanding where synergies are and how successful collaboration can be achieved.
Sebastian Ferse 1, Annette Breckwoldt 1, Kirsten Oleson 2
1 Leibniz Center for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 University of Hawaii Manoa (Honolulu, HI, USA)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 12 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
Over the last decades, several approaches have evolved to counteract the global decline of coral reefs through human interventions. Apart from management and conservation efforts (e.g. implementation of MPAs, improved watershed management and regulation of fisheries – covered in Theme 12), interventions include active restoration through outplacement of cultured corals or coral larvae on denuded natural reefs, and the construction of artificial reefs. In recent years, the acknowledgement of a rapidly changing environment and widespread anthropogenic influences on ecological processes on reefs have led to a rise of interventions focused on augmenting specific functions and processes, such as herbivory, and addressing reef resilience through bioengineering approaches such as assisted evolution and selective breeding. Theme 13 welcomes presentations that relate to these types of interventions.
Madeleine van Oppen 1, Sarah Frias-Torres2, Linda Blackall1, Manuel Aranda3, James Guest4
1 The University of Melbourne (Parkville, Australia)
2 Vulcan Inc. (Seattle, WA, USA)
3 KAUST (Thuwal, Saudi Arabia)
4 Newcastle University (Newcastle, UK)
Coral reefs are home to about a quarter of all marine species, and their economic value far exceeds that of any other ecosystem in the world, including estuaries, tropical rain forests and wetlands. Alarmingly, coral reefs are in rapid decline due to a multitude of anthropogenic activities causing mechanical damage, deteriorating water quality, and ocean acidification and warming. Climate models based on unmitigated greenhouse gas emissions predict heat-induced mass bleaching will occur on most coral reefs every summer within this century, and even under the best-case CO2 emission scenarios oceans will continue to warm and corals will decline further. Corals are capable of adaptation and acclimatisation and resilient reefs may recover unaided, however, natural rates of adaptation and recovery may not be sufficient to keep up with the current rate of global change. To increase the likelihood of coral reef persistence within this century, human interventions that increase coral climate resilience are thus urgently required; not as replacements for conventional management and reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, but as additional interventions integrated with these actions. This half-day session will present developments and findings in the emerging field of assisted evolution (AE). AE includes a variety of bioengineering methods targeted at the coral host animal or any of its associated microbial symbionts, such as assisted gene flow, selective breeding, directed evolution of microbial symbionts, and probiotics. Genetic engineering and synthetic biology approaches are now also beginning to be considered. The half-day session of talks will be followed by a lunch-time panel Q&A discussion. The session will be dedicated to the late Ruth Gates, who was one of the pioneers of AE in corals.
Iliana Baums 1, John Parkinson2, Sarah Davies3, Sheila Kitchen 1, Margaret Miller 2
1 Pennsylvania State University (State College, PA, USA)
2 SECORE International (Hillard, OH, USA)
3 Boston University (Boston, MA, USA)
Coral populations have suffered dramatic declines due to increasing seawater temperatures and other stressors over the past four decades. Because of these declines, several coral species are listed as threatened or endangered. This has prompted a new focus on active coral restoration by scientists, government agencies, NGOs and local communities. Corals pose unique challenges and advantages when designing effective restoration measures due to their life history that includes asexual and sexual reproduction as well as symbioses with microalgae and prokaryotes. The restoration community has recognized the need to design restoration measures based on ecological and evolutionary principles and has asked for guidance from the scientific community. In this session we invite talks that accelerate the design and implementation of successful coral restoration projects. From an evolutionary ecology perspective, the goal of coral restoration efforts is to establish self-sustaining, sexually reproducing populations that have sufficient genetic and phenotypic variation to adapt to changing environments. This requires evidenced-based guidelines to help restoration practitioners meet this goal for most coral species of interest. We anticipate talks that not only address the development of new tools including biomarkers, large-scale genotyping platforms, gene engineering and quantifiable phenotypes but also leverage existing data to answer questions about the scale and speed of adaptation to changing conditions, the role of inbreeding and outbreeding depression, hybridization, gene flow and interactions with symbionts. We will prioritize contributions that blend applied and basic research to spur the development of restoration and conservation practices informed by molecular genetic data and our most current understanding of fundamental ecological principles as they apply to coral populations.
Peter Harrison 1, Dirk Petersen 2
1 Southern Cross University (Lismore, Australia)
2 SECORE International, Inc. (Hilliard, OH, USA)
Coral communities and the reef systems they engineer are declining significantly in most reef regions globally. Loss of corals on many reefs is now so profound that natural coral population recovery via sexual reproduction and recruitment is compromised, leading to ongoing declines in coral community and reef health. Various coral restoration techniques have been used in recent decades to initiate coral populations on small areas of reef but ecologically meaningful reef restoration requires much larger-scale and more cost-effective solutions. This session will focus on recent advances and innovations in coral sexual propagation and scalable multidisciplinary solutions required for successful larger-scale coral restoration and recovery of resilient reef ecosystems.
Sarah Frias-Torres 1, Tom Moore2
1 Vulcan Inc. (Seattle, WA, USA)
2 NOAA Restoration Center (St. Petersburg, FL, USA)
As coral reefs continue to decline worldwide, combining traditional conservation with active restoration is essential to support resilience in these threatened ecosystems. This session will focus both on success stories and strategies for upscaling restoration: to mass-produce bleaching-resistant reef building corals for transplantation onto degraded reefs at the scale of hectares rather than square meters. All methods of mass coral production (Propagation of sexual recruits, asexual propagation by fragmentation and microfragmenting) and transplantation will be considered, including the use of new technologies and automation. Specifically we expect presentations quantifying restoration success including: before-after-control studies of restoration impacts on benthic and fish communities, coral genomics, restoration to dissipate high energy in coastal environments, demographic monitoring in site selection, development of self sustaining thickets, engagement and participation of marginalized base communities, and case studies linking managers priorities with restoration and vice versa.
Ilsa B. Kuffner 1, Joanie A. Kleypas2, Les Kaufman3, Lisa J. Rodrigues4
1 U.S. Geological Survey (St. Petersburg, FL, USA)
2 National Center for Atmospheric Research (Boulder, CO, USA)
3 Boston University (Boston, MA, USA)
4 Villanova University (Villanova, PA, USA)
Coral reef ecosystems exist across a wide range of biophysical settings. Most reef environments can be well characterized by mean, variance, maximum, and minimum water temperature, water clarity, level of nutrients and pollutants, wave energy, exposure to major storms, proximity to land effects (e.g., sedimentation), and exposure to human settlements and coastal development. The biophysical setting, as so characterized, is a large consideration when deciding if, where, and how to restore coral reefs using a rapidly increasing array of gardening and out-planting techniques and other direct interventions. For this session, we invite talks that inform on how we might leverage environmental gradients in biophysical parameters to increase the likelihood of restoration success or natural reef recovery. We seek to draw participation from a wide range of scientific disciplines to foster collaboration among people that do not typically interconnect, including physiologists, geneticists, ecologists, restoration practitioners, resource managers, and more. We welcome observations of phenotypic variance in variables such as coral growth, calcification rates, colony morphology, symbiont assemblages, microbiomes, etc., along any environmental or stress gradient in the field or in the laboratory. Studies that link genetic characterization with phenotypic expression are particularly of value to this session topic. The ability to harness morphological plasticity and stress response in a heterogeneous environment is at the core of creating "coral reefs in waiting," i.e., the collection of pieces required for natural reef reassembly and persistence into the Anthropocene.
Curt Storlazzi1, Shay Viehman2, Mike Beck3
1 U.S. Geological Survey (Santa Cruz, CA, USA)
2 NOAA (Beaufort, NC, USA)
3 University of California, Santa Cruz (Santa Cruz, CA, USA)
Coastal flooding and erosion affects thousands of vulnerable coastal communities and has resulted in hundreds of billions of dollars in damage during the past decade alone; these impacts are predicted to worsen with continued population growth and climate change. There is growing recognition of the role of coral reefs in coastal hazard risk reduction as they dissipate wave energy and produce and trap sediment on adjacent beaches and thus reduce flooding and erosion. Given these benefits, there is the potential to apply coral reef restoration not only to meet ecological recovery goals (coral species, reef communities), but also to reduce coastal hazards and build coastal resilience to current and future storms. To meet and support these joint objectives, there must be rigorous, quantitative assessments of restoration performance, particularly for risk reduction benefits. This mini-symposium focuses on advancements in understanding the role of coral reefs in hazard risk reduction, including but not limited to (i) quantifying the roles of coral spacing, morphology, and attachment strength in boundary-layer hydrodynamics; (ii) relating coral species morphology, structural complexity, or reef location to change in hydrodynamic roughness or induction of wave breaking for different environmental forcing conditions; (iii) design and siting of reef restoration to best reduce coastal flooding for different reef configurations; (iv) comparison of natural "green" and hybrid "gray-green" infrastructure in relation to ecological and hydrodynamic change; (v) incorporation of ecological connectivity into reef restoration site selection; and (vi) cost-benefit analyses of restoration for coastal hazard risk reduction. Summaries of current local or regional-scale studies, including modeling exercises are encouraged, especially if they evaluate social and economic impacts of different restoration options.
Tom Moore1, Tali Vardi1, Petra Lundgren2
1 NOAA Restoration Center (St. Petersburg, FL, USA)
2 Great Barrier Reef Foundation (Brisbane, Australia)
Saving the world's coral reefs will require a multi-pronged approach that ranges from actions at the local to the global level. Globally we need to dramatically and rapidly reduce energy consumption, switch to renewable sources of energy, and conserve carbon-absorbing ecosystems (forests, wetlands, and mangroves). Locally we need to manage threats such as overfishing and pollution, while at the same time repopulating target reefs with resilient, genetically diverse and reproductively viable populations through restoration and novel ecological interventions. Immediate and aggressive action to address these threats, while critical, is only part of the larger equation to ensuring a future for coral reefs and the ecological and economic services they provide. Carbon already released into the atmosphere will continue to warm ocean waters to a level inhospitable to corals for decades to come. Increased bleaching combined with reproductive failures and continually decreasing population size sets the stage for complete ecological collapse. If the critical ecologic and economic functions that corals reefs provide the world today are to be preserved, it is necessary to buy time and increase ecosystem resilience in the shorter term. Coral reef restoration can help span the predicted gap between the present when existing coral populations are threatened with extinction, and a future ocean that is hospitable again to corals. Current work is showing that restoration of reefs is possible, and the spatial scale of success is steadily increasing. In the near future, by harnessing promising research on novel ecological and genetic intervention strategies, restored reefs may be more resilient than their natural counterparts. Working to close the gap between success at the local level and impact at the ecosystem level will not be easy or quick, but in the face of a rapidly declining population is necessary to maintain the ecosystem services that coral reefs provide.
Edwin A. Hernández-Delgado1, Samuel E. Suleimán-Ramos1, Elisa Bayraktarov2, Phanor Montoya-Maya3
1 Sociedad Ambiente Marino (San Juan, Puerto Rico)
2 The University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
3 Corales de Paz (Santiago de Cali, Colombia)
Coral reefs worldwide are degrading rapidly due to climate change, overfishing, pollution and coastal development. In areas where natural recovery is negligible or where conservation is not enough, restoration – or the process of assisting the recovery of a disturbed ecosystem, may become critical. The Reef Futures 2018 conference brought together a large international community of reef restoration experts, businesses, and civil organizations and galvanized them to joint efforts to save coral reefs through restoration. During the conference we found that, in contrast to other coral reef areas in the world, learnings from long-term and ongoing coral reef restoration projects done by scientists and practitioners especially in the Spanish-speaking parts of the Caribbean and Eastern Tropical Pacific were poorly shared with the international scientific community. This session aims to showcase major coral reef restoration projects from the Caribbean and Eastern Tropical Pacific and invite for collaboration and knowledge transfer between coral reef restoration projects elsewhere in the world. We will specifically focus on the motivations for these restoration efforts, their total project cost, spatial extent, and recent advances. Restoration interventions using different techniques will be presented and their successes (or failures) evaluated. This is the first ICRS symposium focused at overcoming the language barriers between Spanish and English for coral reef restoration. It aims to connect international researchers, practitioners and resource managers on the mission of restoring global coral reefs.
Sebastian Ferse1, Ronald Osinga2
1 Leibniz Center for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 University of Wageningen (Wageningen, The Netherlands)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 13 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.
The situation of coral reefs seems getting direr every day. It becomes obvious that we are deep in a coral reef crisis. This crisis can only be solved through a combination of international climate change mitigation action and local/regional measures, such as reduction of stressors or interventions like active restoration. To trigger and support this, people need to be aware of the importance of coral reef ecosystems and the current problems they are facing. Coral reefs are among the most important ecosystems on earth, because they provide crucial ecosystem services such as high productivity, tourism income, and coastal protection. However, alarmingly many people are not even aware that hard corals are tiny animals that accomplish the build-up of massive reef structures, i.e. the basic knowledge about coral reefs is often not existing.
There is a large science community, revealing astonishing facts about coral reefs in a high frequency. But do we communicate this successfully to the public and decision makers? And how should we communicate the dramatic situation of coral reefs to the public in a way that we generate a positive echo? There are already many efforts and attempts to reaching out to the public to communicate coral reef related matters - some are more successful than others. What is the best approach? What tools can be used to communicate messages, and what, in fact, should be the messages? This theme aims to answer these questions and thereby welcomes people that are interested in communication, outreach, and education.
Carin Jantzen1, Christian Wild2
1 SECORE International (Hilliard, OH, USA)
2 University of Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
This open session invites all contributions that relate to Theme 14.
Observations of reefs thriving in unexpected locations, or inverted predatory food webs or the persistence under heavy pollution or turbidity have thrown up unresolved challenges in our understanding of coral reefs. New data promise new vantage points if they can be assimilated into models of reef system function, both conceptual and predictive, and thus engage with the challenges of coral reef science. Reef conservation efforts are underpinned by assumptions about the current theories and future trajectories of reefs, underlining the urgency for new and improved understanding of coral reefs. This session invites contributions towards modeling and forecasting of coral reefs, especially in inter-disciplinary conceptual frameworks. Innovative uses of long-term records towards predicting reef state in the present or the future will be valued. An emphasis will also be on tools and model results that improve communication between various stakeholders and scientific disciplines.
William Skirving 1, Mark Eakin2, Ove Hoegh-Guldberg3, Simon Donner4, Neal Cantin5
1 NOAA (Cranbrook, Australia)
2 NOAA (College Park, MD, USA)
3 University of Qeensland (Brisbane, Australia)
4 University of British Columbia (Vancouver, Canada)
5 Australian Institute of Marine Science (Cape Cleveland, Australia)
1998 is recognised as being the first global mass bleaching event. It was subsequently followed by global events in 2010, 2015, 2016 and 2017 with the last three a single event that began in 2014 and continued into 2017. The 2014-17 global coral bleaching event was the longest, most extensive, most intense (in terms of accumulated heat stress), and probably most damaging (in terms of coral mortality) ever recorded. The event coincided with three consecutive record-setting years for globally averaged surface temperature: 2014 set a record that was surpassed in 2015, which in turn was surpassed in 2016; global temperature during 2017 became the third-highest on record. Anomalously warm ocean temperature patterns through this period were associated with the El Niño-Southern Oscillation, and oceanographic phenomena, such as "the blob". Mass coral bleaching has been long-associated with temperature above expected summertime conditions. Many coral reef areas experienced their worst observed bleaching and more than half bleached twice or more during the 36-month period. While the 2014/17 global mass bleaching event was the first multi-year bleaching event, was this event a precursor of things to come? A more complete understanding of this and previous mass coral bleaching events is needed. Towards this goal, it is helpful to examine global and regional heat stress and subsequent mass coral bleaching through time, including past, present, and future. To achieve this analyses requires the use of all available tools and data. To date, satellite products such as those developed by NOAA Coral Reef Watch have dominated global and long-term analyses, however other data sets are as valuable or even more valuable. For example, bleaching data from coral cores and from in situ surveys are essential. While satellite heat stress products record what the corals should experience, we must also know what they did experience. Understanding future coral bleaching requires a good understanding of what has happened in the past and what might happen in the future. Climate models are therefore an invaluable inclusion to this suite of tools as we seek to understand the fate of corals in a warming world. This session seeks papers and posters that utilize any and all data to improve our understanding of mass coral bleaching in time and space. It also wishes to include new and improved methodologies and tools for shedding light on our understanding of mass coral bleaching in the past, present, and future.
Becky Twohey1, Malin Pinsky2
1 Coral Reef Alliance (Oakland, CA, USA)
2 Rutgers University (New Brunswick, NJ, USA)
Coral reefs are already experiencing the effects of climate change and projections from recent bleaching suggest widespread decline of existing reefs. On the other hand, reef-building corals have successfully coped with environmental change over their evolutionary history. Can evolution also help corals cope with rapid rates of current and future environmental change? While some models suggest that it can’t, others offer hope. This session seeks contributions from ecology, evolutionary biology, physiology, genomics, geology, and conservation biology to understand the potential for evolutionary rescue in corals. Evolutionary rescue occurs when advantageous genetic adaptation saves a population that would otherwise go extinct due to a drastic environmental change. Possible talk topics include the influences of population size, demographic connectivity, and diversity (e.g., genomic, phenotypic, symbiont, and species) on evolutionary rescue; deep time perspectives on coral evolution and environmental change; physiological mechanisms for evolution of higher thermal tolerance; genomic responses to bleaching; or conservation mechanisms to facilitate evolutionary rescue. This session seeks to include case studies of coral adaptation or recovery, eco-evolutionary modeling projects, and mechanistic research, and contributions that describe management actions that facilitate evolutionary rescue at different spatial scales.
Hauke Reuter 1, Sönke Hohn1, Jaap Kaandorp2
1 Leibniz Centre for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 University of Amsterdam (Amsterdam, The Netherlands)
Coral reefs rely on the fragile balance of processes that interact between various components on different spatio-temporal scales and allow the establishment of healthy coral reef ecosystems. Mathematical simulation models are increasingly important tools to summarize our current understanding of the processes affecting the resilience and vulnerability of coral reef ecosystems to anthropogenic and natural disturbances. The integration of knowledge from different disciplines into mathematical models facilitates the identification of regionally important drivers and contributes to science-based management, and also allows identifying knowledge gaps for future research. The proposed session welcomes all contributions that highlight the added value of model applications to advance our understanding of coral reef ecosystems and their potential response to future environmental change. Such approaches include statistical modeling and data analysis, dynamic modeling of biogeochemical, ecological, and physiological processes that affect reef status, as well as models for management that interlink ecological and human domains. In order to develop informed coral reef management strategies, we need an overarching understanding of reef related processes utilizing newly established data bases, and integrating interdisciplinary knowledge in numerical simulations. In this session we want to bring together scientists from different approaches to summarize the huge innovative potential of simulation models for reef research and to discuss the uncertain future of coral reefs. We also welcome contributions that aim to use this knowledge to develop coral reef management strategies to help coral reefs cope with anthropogenic and natural disturbances.
Thomas Mann1, Paul Kench2
1 Leibniz Centre for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 Simon Fraser University (Burnaby, Canada)
Coral reef islands represent the product of interactions between ecological and physical processes on coral reef platforms. Due to their low-lying nature and the intricate connections between sea level, reef growth, reef ecology and wave processes, coral reef islands are likely facing a transitional phase resulting from climate change and future sea-level rise. However, the morphological response of reef islands to these changing boundary conditions is still poorly resolved. Such transformation in island and reef-fringed coastlines is of critical concern to coastal communities. A major challenge for reef island science is to improve projections of how islands will respond to climatic change and associated sea-level rise over the 21st century. Addressing this gap in reef island science requires improved knowledge of; (i) the intimate linkages between reef ecology and processes that modulate sediment supply to islands; (ii) the nearshore hydrodynamics that force island physical change and (iii) understanding of the morphodynamics of islands. This session invites contributions that span and/or integrate these complementary fields of expertise with a focus on islands and island change. We aim to bring together experts from the fields of reef geology, geomorphology, paleontology, biology, ecology, remote sensing and wave and climate modeling in order to determine the state of the art and discuss future research directions.
James Robinson 1, Alice Rogers2, Kirsty Nash3, Shaun Wilson4
1 Lancaster University (Lancaster, UK)
2 Victoria University of Wellington (Wellington, New Zealand)
3 Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies (Hobart, Australia)
4 Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions (Australia)
Coral reef fisheries are a conduit for many valuable ecosystem goods and services. For people, seafood products are of high nutritional value and an important source of income to many coastal communities. For reef ecosystems, fishing can influence ecosystem functioning through selective removal of species and individuals, often flattening biomass pyramids and reducing biodiversity. Yet as marine heatwaves cause declines in coral habitat and tropical fishes migrate polewards in response to long-term ocean warming, climate impacts are also altering the structure and function of fish assemblages to produce new and unexpected ecological configurations. In response, coral reef fishers are exploiting increases in herbivore productivity after coral bleaching events, while the tropicalization of fish communities is altering catch compositions at regional scales. Future tropical fisheries will thus be constrained by ecological responses to climate change (e.g. how species compositions change), and be shaped by how coastal communities interact with altered ecosystems. Examples from Kenya suggest that ecosystem protection through gear regulation can compensate for climate impacts while, for Pacific islands, gear diversification may help fishers to target climate change 'winners', such as pelagic fishes. For food security, trade networks could be harnessed to ensure that climate-impacted regions can access seafood, but this will require an improved understanding of the nutritional implications of climate changes.
Marleen Stuhr1, Christiane Schmidt2, Martina de Freitas Prazeres 3
1 Leibniz Centre for Tropical Marine Research (Bremen, Germany)
2 University of Angers (Angers, France)
3 Naturalis Biodiversity Center (Leiden, The Netherlands)
Anthropogenic impacts are transforming coral reefs at an unprecedented rate, changing species diversity and composition, and ultimately altering ecosystem services. Photosymbiont-bearing large benthic foraminifera (LBF) are crucial carbonate producers in reefs, and modify the benthic environment through the production of calcium carbonate. As with reef-building corals, they rely on symbiosis with algae to prosper in shallow tropical seas. Throughout the Cenozoic hothouse climate LBF dominated shallow carbonate platforms, during which the concentration of atmospheric CO2 and seawater temperatures significantly exceeded current values. Modern LBF are ideally suited as bioindicators of water quality due to their sensitivity to environmental changes. LBF are also often used as model systems for studying (photo)symbiosis due to their short generational times (weeks to months). In addition, LBF are easily maintained in aquarium systems, and their small physical size avoids many logistical problems with other model organisms. Recent experimental studies and reports from extreme reef habitats have shown that some LBF are resistant to temporal or regional variations in environmental conditions, and are able to quickly respond to such changes. This may be due to the presence of a high diversity in algal symbiont types and the flexibility/specificity of algae and bacteria present in their microbiome. Finally, molecular approaches unveiled cryptic diversity and mechanisms of cellular acclimatization. We invite contributions on the latest research on LBF. Specially, we encourage submissions addressing: the application of LBF in coral reef assessments, the use of LBF in microbiome studies, LBF as model organisms for photosymbiosis, the consequences of LBF range expansions and studies on their general response to varying environmental stressors. This session aims to increase our understanding of the biodiversity and ecological importance of LBF in future reef environments.
Arjun Chennu 1, Emma Kennedy 2
1 MPI Bremen (Bremen, Germany)
2 University of Queensland (Brisbane, Australia)
This open session invites contributions related to Theme 15 that do not feel addressed by the above specialised sessions.